Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

BTS

Community Moderator
  • Posts

    43,090
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    21

 Content Type 

Profiles

Toronto Blue Jays Videos

2026 Toronto Blue Jays Top Prospect Rankings

Toronto Blue Jays Trade & Free Agent Rumors

Toronto Blue Jays Fan Guides & Resources

2025 Toronto Blue Jays Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Toronto Blue Jays News, Rumors & Analysis

2026 Toronto Blue Jays Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by BTS

  1. I just think we'd be expecting too much from his back. He's 29, when defense slides anyway, and is coming off disc surgery. It's just really hard to see him being good enough out there to provide value with a league average bat and neutral baserunning.
  2. If you pencil him in as a +5 defender he can probably give you 1-1.5 wins. You can probably squeeze league-average play out of a Gose/Pillar platoon. Unless one of them gets hurt and/or sucks balls. I actually don't hate the idea if LF is more reliable than a Dirks/Mayberry/Pompey triumvirate.
  3. Gose is going to be like 20-25% below average offensively in LF. I'm not sure hes good enough defensively to be a 1+ win player out there.
  4. In no way am I happy about the prospect of Dirks being the team's best LF.
  5. A healthy Dirks is probably the best LF on the team with Pompey in CF if he can still play defense. He's probably finished though.
  6. So if Pompey is the starting CF, we have: RF - Bautista CF - Pompey LF - Dirks BN - Gose BN - Mayberry AAA - Pillar I dunno, that's pretty uninspiring to me. Pompey has huge risk, Dirks' back is f***ed up, and Mayberry sucks. I think they really need to bring in one more player with bankable production.
  7. They never learn. Every time a player can feasibly be defended as a major league player, he makes the team instead of being held in AAA as quality depth.
  8. I don't know anything about Tropeano. Is he a guy?
  9. Over Thole? Absolutely.
  10. That's valid. I think they're both replacement level, but with framing undervalued it's easier to significantly upgrade C than 2B. Should have acquired Conger.
  11. IMO: 1. C 2. 2B 3. OF 4. bench 5. bullpen
  12. AA is probably despairing them by offering Happ and wanting Kendrick's contract covered.
  13. Is Dirks still capable of that level of play? League-average hitter with no platoon splits and no baserunning value. You have to assume he's still a good LF defender at 29 after disk surgery to pencil him in at 1+ WAR.
  14. Four replacement-level starters, an awful bench, and weak bullpen isn't doing it for you?
  15. I have no idea where you guys find the time.
  16. I have no idea who those guys are.
  17. There just isn't a whole lot out there. Assuming Sandoval and Hanley are too expensive, you have Lowrie, Cabrera, Drew, and Headley. IMO Cabrera is going to get a multi-year deal and is a decent bet to tank completely, and Drew really isn't bankable at all. Headley and Lowrie on ~3/40 deals are really the only attractive options.
  18. They could roll with Greiss + Gustavsson/Enroth/Fasth next year and get the same value for like 1/3 of what they'll spend.
  19. It makes sense to keep Pompey in AAA if they can. That way when someone goes down you have a proper backup. They really should add an OF though. Right now it's Bautista, and then a bunch of low-ceiling high-risk guys who might contribute if things go well. An Aoki would be great.
  20. Updated with arbitration projections. C – Navarro (5) 1B – Encarnacion (10) 2B – 3B – Lawrie (arb1 proj. 1.8) SS – Reyes (22) RF – Bautista (14) CF – Gose (nm) LF – Dirks (arb3 proj. 1.6) DH – Smoak (arb2 proj. 3) 2B/3B – Maicer Izturis (3) OF - John Mayberry Jr. (arb2 proj. 1.9) 3B - Valencia (arb1 proj. 1.7) C - Thole (1.75) SP – Dickey (12) SP – Buehrle (19) SP –Romero (7.5) SP - Happ (6.7) SP – Hutchison (nm) SP – Stroman (nm) RP - Estrada (arb3 proj. 4.7) RP – Brett Cecil (arb2 proj. 2.6) RP – Aaron Loup (nm) RP – Todd Redmond (nm) RP - Liam Hendriks (nm) $118.75 M Free Agents Melky Cabrera Colby Rasmus Casey Janssen Other Arb-Eligible Dan Johnson (arb3) Munenori Kawasaki (arb1) Juan Francisco (arb2)
  21. What a stupid waste of money.
  22. Dodgers have figured that throwing cash at the front office is the best way to spend.
  23. Ugh, again: I'm not giving a cash reward to the winner.
  24. Ewww. That's two pure DH's who just to maybe get a 110 wRC+ from the position.
×
×
  • Create New...