Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
12 minutes ago, james jones said:

Johan Santana should've made the HOF if Felix Hernandez makes it.

Santana from 2004 on was one of the most dominant arms in the game. I remember attending the 2006 Home Opener and it was Halladay vs. Santana on Opening Day which was awesome.

If he stayed healthy, he probably could have been a 60-WAR arm. His career ended at age 31. 

He did show a period of dominance and being one of the best arms in the league. 

 

Community Moderator
Posted

Santana had a HoF peak, but pitched before we've adjusted volume expectations for SPs. But even by today's standards he was probably like 2 healthy seasons away from having the longevity. Jacob DeGrom, who a lot of people still think doesn't have the longevity, has already K'd more guys than Santana (Santana fell short of 2000 Ks) and is ahead by like 5 fWAR. DeGrom about 300 IP away from Santana. If their careers had overlapped I think DeGrom has better case if he never throws another pitch. 

Community Moderator
Posted

Felix has Santana by like 9 fWAR, 700 IP, and 500Ks and they had similar peaks. Santana has the extra CY and Triple Crown, and Felix has a couple of extra AS selections and the 1-team bump. If Felix is barely getting in I think its fair to say Santana falls just short. 

Posted
8 hours ago, Brownie19 said:

I just wanted to say that all the Toronto sports major sports teams suck balls.  Raps and Leafs have combined to lose the last 11 games at the ACC.  Just horrendous efforts.  Following the Jays 5th place finish in the AL East and it seems like all our teams are struggling to meet expectations.  Brutal times!  The question is - which team will turn it around first?  Jays, Leafs or the Raps?

How about the Argos and their loss against Winnipeg a couple weeks ago? Geez. 

Posted
7 hours ago, BTS said:

Santana had a HoF peak, but pitched before we've adjusted volume expectations for SPs. But even by today's standards he was probably like 2 healthy seasons away from having the longevity. Jacob DeGrom, who a lot of people still think doesn't have the longevity, has already K'd more guys than Santana (Santana fell short of 2000 Ks) and is ahead by like 5 fWAR. DeGrom about 300 IP away from Santana. If their careers had overlapped I think DeGrom has better case if he never throws another pitch. 

Yeah with Santana I'm on the fence, but eventually I think he ends up falling short. He had a HoF peak especially from 2004-2006 and still had some real solid seasons afterwards, but yeah lacks the longevity. I think if he put up a couple more high 6 to 7 WAR seasons like he did from 2004-2006, you can make a case based on his dominance and being one of the top arms in the games during the 2000's. 

Community Moderator
Posted
9 hours ago, Brownie19 said:

I just wanted to say that all the Toronto sports major sports teams suck balls.  Raps and Leafs have combined to lose the last 11 games at the ACC.  Just horrendous efforts.  Following the Jays 5th place finish in the AL East and it seems like all our teams are struggling to meet expectations.  Brutal times!  The question is - which team will turn it around first?  Jays, Leafs or the Raps?

Raptors easily 

Kawhi is hurt and they have blown big leads in lots of these recent losses. They aren't bad.

The Leafs are so horrible it's hilarious and they have no first rounders for two years.... a decade of sadness incoming. 

Posted
1 hour ago, Laika said:

Raptors easily 

Kawhi is hurt and they have blown big leads in lots of these recent losses. They aren't bad.

The Leafs are so horrible it's hilarious and they have no first rounders for two years.... a decade of sadness incoming. 

I hope you're right, but they are 5-9 man.  It's gross.  Kawhi or not, it's just underwhelming effort after underwhelming effort.

You think any coaches get canned?  Can the Leafs just fire the GM and coach after 23 games?  Essentially all the experts questioned both hiring from Day 1.  It appears they're right.  Just boot these losers.

Community Moderator
Posted
11 minutes ago, Brownie19 said:

I hope you're right, but they are 5-9 man.  It's gross.  Kawhi or not, it's just underwhelming effort after underwhelming effort.

You think any coaches get canned?  Can the Leafs just fire the GM and coach after 23 games?  Essentially all the experts questioned both hiring from Day 1.  It appears they're right.  Just boot these losers.

I don't think the Leafs GM has anything to worry about, he didn't make this mess. 

Coach criticisms will be valid after the season but for now it's mostly about how little he is playing McKenna which is tough. The kid is tiny. 

Community Moderator
Posted

Some names unprotected who were formerly "top prospects" at least on team lists. Stole from Twitter 


- Gage Stanifer (TOR)
- Karson Milbrandt (MIA)
- Brayden Taylor (MIA)
- Jacob Reimer (NYM)
- Ryan Clifford (NYM)
- Brock Wilken (MIL)
- Termarr Johnson (PIT)
- Creed Willems (BAL)

Community Moderator
Posted

Another list 

Top 10 Rule 5 eligible prospects left off 40-man rosters today:

 

1. Jacob Reimer, 3B, NYM

2. Aroon Escobar, 2B, PHI

3. Karson Milbrandt, SP, MIA

4. Allen Facundo, SP, NYY

5. Kemp Alderman, RF, MIA

6. Jack Wenninger, SP, NYM

7. Gage Stanifer, SP, TOR

8. Jansel Luis, 3B, AZ

9. Brayden Taylor, 3B, MIA

10. Roc Riggio, 2B, COL

Posted
50 minutes ago, Laika said:

I don't think the Leafs GM has anything to worry about, he didn't make this mess. 

Coach criticisms will be valid after the season but for now it's mostly about how little he is playing McKenna which is tough. The kid is tiny. 

I don't know man, John Chayka added like 10-12 new players this offseason. He shook up the team and against all odds, have made them even worse.

Almost everyone said John Chayka was a f*cking loser, and it seems they were correct.

Community Moderator
Posted
22 minutes ago, Brownie19 said:

I don't know man, John Chayka added like 10-12 new players this offseason. He shook up the team and against all odds, have made them even worse.

Almost everyone said John Chayka was a f*cking loser, and it seems they were correct.

Most were pretty insignificant though, like trading a third rounder for a third liner like Nick Paul. 

I think he nailed the Marchenko trade which was a big swing.

Too early to tell on Raddysh. I think he is playing "fine" but needs to do more. 

Bobrovsky signing is bad.  

Roslovic signing was awesome. Some of the more minor signings aren't working out right now, Sissons and Duhaime in particular. 


Ultimately, it's just some good with some bad. But I like some of the process. The team was in a tough spot when he took over, with all of their core "stars" 29 or older and under term. Inherited mistakes like the Tanev and Tavares and McCabe and OEL deals. His path was predetermined, he basically had to keep trying with this core and there was always a high probability that one of Nylander or Matthews would just kind of get worse. Nylander looks like he has declined IMO.  

 

Also, his sister is hot. 

Community Moderator
Posted

The Bobrovsky signing is the weirdest NHL deal in years. He looked washed last year at 37 and the team gives him 3 x7 for his age 38-40 seasons? Completely asinine 

Posted
Just now, BTS said:

The Bobrovsky signing is the weirdest NHL deal in years. He looked washed last year at 37 and the team gives him 3 x7 for his age 38-40 seasons? Completely asinine 

100% - I thought he should have been canned the second the ink dried on that one.

Community Moderator
Posted
39 minutes ago, Terminator said:

 

I think the Royals are going to come out ahead here. Miller hasn't put it together yet but he has great stuff, three pitches, and command. Seattle doesn't seem to have any idea how to get pitchers to reach their potential these days. And they also get Ferrer who was considered very valuable last offseason then struggled in Seattle despite top-notch stuff. 

Garcia seems like the kind of hitter who goes to Seattle and is never heard from again. 

Posted
2 minutes ago, BTS said:

I think the Royals are going to come out ahead here. Miller hasn't put it together yet but he has great stuff, three pitches, and command. Seattle doesn't seem to have any idea how to get pitchers to reach their potential these days. And they also get Ferrer who was considered very valuable last offseason then struggled in Seattle despite top-notch stuff. 

Garcia seems like the kind of hitter who goes to Seattle and is never heard from again. 

Yeah it seems like a big trade but I wouldn't be surprised if neither side gets much out of it. Enigmas, relievers, and prospects exchanging hands.

Garcia had a huge 2025 but tough to get back on track as a right in that ballpark. And he actually makes some money unlike everyone else in the deal. Royals getting Ferrer is a nice piece too.

Community Moderator
Posted

I wonder if this means Seattle isn't trading Kirby. His value most be very low because he sucked last year, and his last season before FA might be lost to a lockout. 

Posted

Such an interesting trade.  I think most like a lot of the underlying metrics for Garcia's bat, but it certainly looks like 2025 might be the outlier and he might just be a below average hitter.

  • Seattle thinks they can fix Garcia
  • KC thinks they can fix Miller and Ferrer. 

We'll find out whether either of them are right.

Community Moderator
Posted

Royals are insane to do this 

Seattle pitchers are Fool's Gold. 

Garcia doesn't even need fixing, who cares if he never hits 16 homers again, he's still a 26 year old good defensive 3B who makes contact and hits the ball hard on a sweet contract for four more seasons. That seems like a 3 WAR player regardless of power coming back.  Also a good baserunner. 

Miller is much more of a performance risk, he has had HR issues in recent years and has been destroyed on the road in his entire career. He projects worse and it's not even that close. He's also a freaking pitcher so watch him blow his elbow out. Ferrer should be a solid late relief option but that's not the kind of asset I would want to close the value gap. 

Community Moderator
Posted

I feel like the pressure of a potential lockout is causing more action to occur right now which is nice for change 

Old-Timey Member
Posted

I can kinda see the logic in trading Garcia from the Royals perspective if they believe 2025 was a fluke. His defense alone will make him valuable, but a team that cheap/low payroll has to guess right on their extensions, and if this was a potential Andres Gimenez type of situation in their eyes where they paid him based on a big year and they lost faith in that continuing, then it's probably better to cut bait a year early than a year late when the salary starts to balloon up. I don't think the Royals make this trade if he was arbitration eligible right now, but who knows. 

Posted
32 minutes ago, Laika said:

Royals are insane to do this 

Seattle pitchers are Fool's Gold. 

Garcia doesn't even need fixing, who cares if he never hits 16 homers again, he's still a 26 year old good defensive 3B who makes contact and hits the ball hard on a sweet contract for four more seasons. That seems like a 3 WAR player regardless of power coming back.  Also a good baserunner. 

Miller is much more of a performance risk, he has had HR issues in recent years and has been destroyed on the road in his entire career. He projects worse and it's not even that close. He's also a freaking pitcher so watch him blow his elbow out. Ferrer should be a solid late relief option but that's not the kind of asset I would want to close the value gap. 

Players who get their value from defense aren't worth nearly as much right?  right?

If Garcia is a sub 100 wRC+ bat, is he much better than Ernie Clement (if we assume he's still a stud defensively if left at 3rd base)?  He's younger and has more control of course - but still.

Community Moderator
Posted
54 minutes ago, Brownie19 said:

Players who get their value from defense aren't worth nearly as much right?  right?

If Garcia is a sub 100 wRC+ bat, is he much better than Ernie Clement (if we assume he's still a stud defensively if left at 3rd base)?  He's younger and has more control of course - but still.

It's a loaded question. Garcia has a 109 wRC+ projection for a reason. 

Posted
21 minutes ago, Laika said:

It's a loaded question. Garcia has a 109 wRC+ projection for a reason. 

I understand how project systems work, but I still take them with a grain of salt.  If Garcia is a 110 wRC+ hitter, then he's a really solid player.

If he's a 99 wRC+ hitter again, than he's 2025 Ernie Clement.

Community Moderator
Posted
3 minutes ago, Brownie19 said:

I understand how project systems work, but I still take them with a grain of salt.  If Garcia is a 110 wRC+ hitter, then he's a really solid player.

If he's a 99 wRC+ hitter again, than he's 2025 Ernie Clement.

??? 

And if my aunt had wheels she'd be a bike 

What are we supposed to learn by saying "if this guy is worse than he should be"?

He's not comparable to Ernie like, at all. Garcia is a generally well rounded hitter who walks and hits the ball decently hard. Some batted ball profile issues. Like a mini Yandy Diaz. 

Ernie is a poof who never walks but makes elite contact and pulls everything in the air, he's super weird. 

There are reasons that MG has a full season 120 wRC+ on his resume. Someone like Ernie is physically and spiritually incapable of ever doing that

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Blue Jays community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...