Blue Jays (Scherzer) vs Royals (Lorenzen): 9/19/25, 7:40pm

[HomeRunHomer]

Max is cooked.

[neverbeenhere]

what a shame 

[Rimar]

It's time to sit Scherzer few games, and only use Gausman, Bassitt,  Berrios, Bieber and Yesevage. 

[Jesusindashed]

Who are these announcers holy s*** they are awful and so is this game

[Barrelsandbombs]

Just LOL

[bronson44]

Jesus Christ

[Rimar]

Just now, HomeRunHomer said:

Max is cooked.

He's probably injured

[Stangstag]

Just now, Wake n bake said:

Def what we are all feeling just not saying lol 

Im not upset, just disappointed. Thought Scherzer would be a weapon in the playoffs but looks like he’s washed his last few starts.

[bones]

Just now, Rimar said:

He's probably injured

nah hes just old as f*** 

[Omar]

2 minutes ago, Masterbather said:

I've been told that the home runs are not a concern and Max is a lock for the postseason rotation by those that know so much better. 

 

It's all in your head MB.

[416BlueJs]

This is brutal. Cause for concern heading into playoffs. And may have to play WC games if they keep it up

[Jays24]

Time to throw Scherzer in the bullpen and hope he can air it all out for 1 inning.  Will he be a team player about it and/or do the Jays management team even have the balls to do it.

[Rimar]

Just now, Stangstag said:

Im not upset, just disappointed. Thought Scherzer would be a weapon in the playoffs but looks like he’s washed his last few starts.

If Yesevage have difficulties in his next few starts, Lauer should get a new chance as SP.

[Perfect Game]

6 minutes ago, Wake n bake said:

Would someone message that idiot on X or something and tell him it’s Pete walker 

Already did.

[bronson44]

Just now, Stangstag said:

Im not upset, just disappointed. Thought Scherzer would be a weapon in the playoffs but looks like he’s washed his last few starts.

Yeah I thought so too. Was a point where I thought we should start looking to bring him back on another 1 year deal next year.

[Jesusindashed]

You got to take him out holy s*** 

[Horses Fart]

Ok so that might be the dagger. Max’s crazy eye must be looking elsewhere. 

[Omar]

10 minutes ago, neverbeenhere said:

that doesn't seem to work though. 

I checked and it works.  Maybe for the best at this point based on the score.

[ComeTogether]

Mercy pull pls

[Rimar]

8 minutes ago, bones said:

Scherzer is finished 

Unfortunately Atkins if he lose Bieber and Bassitt in free agency,  he will probably bring back Scherzer at low cost

[Abomination]

The Royals were on absolutely everything. He's probably tipping pitches again or something. 

[Big_Walleye]

Omg! 8⅓ to cover without a long man.  Better hope they extend the lead so Heineman, France and Straw can cover innings.

[Masterbather]

1 minute ago, Omar said:

It's all in your head MB.

It's crazy because we've all seen the home runs we've all seen the deep fly balls game after game and people were just like nah it's good. 

People were trying way too hard to convince themselves that Max is something that he's not anymore.

I mean he's not THIS bad. It's just an especially bad inning but he's average at this point.

[Spanky__99]

8 minutes ago, Waylanderz said:

This is not Scherzer's night.

He got his ass waxed!!!

 

[Horses Fart]

Hiney get a couple innings tonight? 

[ComeTogether]

3 minutes ago, Big_Walleye said:

Omg! 8⅓ to cover without a long man.  Better hope they extend the lead so Heineman, France and Straw can cover innings.

Vladdy can pitch. 

[Stangstag]

Well, i think we can officially stick a fork in the Max Scherzer deal. 

Ends up looking like a pretty bad signing. I suppose you could point to intangibles like coaching the younger guys, but that’s not worth 15million lol.

[neverbeenhere]

Until Max Scherzer joined bluejays, I had always thought heterochromia was for cats 

[Stangstag]

5 minutes ago, Rimar said:

Unfortunately Atkins if he lose Bieber and Bassitt in free agency,  he will probably bring back Scherzer at low cost

No chance

[Omar]

3 minutes ago, Masterbather said:

It's crazy because we've all seen the home runs we've all seen the deep fly balls game after game and people were just like nah it's good. 

People were trying way too hard to convince themselves that Max is something that he's not anymore.

I mean he's not THIS bad. It's just an especially bad inning but he's average at this point.

Yeah I've been skeptical about him as well which is why you won't find a post from me saying he's a lock for the playoff rotation.  He had a bad night. Oh well. 

Let the comeback commence.