Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
smoak and mirrors bat... unless he accidentally runs into one he's not doing anything with the stick

 

All a pitcher needs to do is to continuously flip breaking balls up there and he'll whiff steady, even hangers. Even if you tell him it's coming, he'll still whiff.

  • Replies 78
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
another player taken out by a bad slide into second base? sprinklers, second base, the dugout stairs and the shower.... dangerous work place environment

 

It's kind of impressive that it's a SB attempt that puts Pillar out instead of the hundred possible fractures and concussions he's somehow avoided while playing like a wrecking ball in the OF. We're going to miss Superman, I predict.

Community Moderator
Posted
All a pitcher needs to do is to continuously flip breaking balls up there and he'll whiff steady, even hangers. Even if you tell him it's coming, he'll still whiff.

 

pretty much

 

 

glad he got rewarded with an extension SMH

Community Moderator
Posted
It's kind of impressive that it's a SB attempt that puts Pillar out instead of the hundred possible fractures and concussions he's somehow avoided while playing like a wrecking ball in the OF. We're going to miss Superman, I predict.

 

I know. We all expected him to die running through the center field wall, not be attacked by the dirt around second base.

Posted
I agree. Upton in a corner OF spot over Saunders or Bautista is worth over a full WAR by itself. Smoak's bat (projected 96 wRC+) over Upton's (83) doesn't make up the difference. Also need to factor in EE's defense vs. Smoak's but my lying eyes can't really tell the difference. EE probably better range but Smoak has better footwork and glovework around the bag.

 

I guess the one argument for Smoak getting PT is that he and Upton's platoon splits might make it more beneficial to have Smoak play against righties and Upton play against lefties.

 

I think it's time to start EE 80% of the time at 1B for the remainder of the year and rotate the DH spot amongst the four outfielders. Pompey could play a role in September also.

Posted
It's kind of impressive that it's a SB attempt that puts Pillar out instead of the hundred possible fractures and concussions he's somehow avoided while playing like a wrecking ball in the OF. We're going to miss Superman, I predict.

 

Upton plays a solid CF, we'll be ok for a few weeks.

Old-Timey Member
Posted

 

It's hard to imagine 2 players being worse. I have never seen Smoak hit a curveball that wasn't hung over the middle of the plate.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
So we can't get through 40 maturely discussed posts before you chime in, hey joNn?

 

I just thought it was obvious. Sorry Grubs.

Community Moderator
Posted
It's hard to imagine 2 players being worse. I have never seen Smoak hit a curveball that wasn't hung over the middle of the plate.

 

that's only because we get to see Smoak suck regularly

Posted
It's hard to imagine 2 players being worse. I have never seen Smoak hit a curveball that wasn't hung over the middle of the plate.

 

well Lind is the one in 1st place. And we all know how bad he was when he was here

Old-Timey Member
Posted
well Lind is the one in 1st place. And we all know how bad he was when he was here

 

Jon Morosi thinks we should trade for Lind to replace Smoak. He would fit right in!

Posted
well Lind is the one in 1st place. And we all know how bad he was when he was here

 

I don't remember Lind being as bad as Smoak when he was here.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
I don't remember Lind being as bad as Smoak when he was here.

 

The high fastball was always his kryptonite

Posted
Jon Morosi thinks we should trade for Lind to replace Smoak. He would fit right in!

 

I think he said Morneau would be his first realistic option.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
I think he said Morneau would be his first realistic option.

 

I heard Lind and McCann but if he said Morneau good for him. If he clears. He makes next to nothing.

Posted
I think he said Morneau would be his first realistic option.

 

I wanted the Jays to go after Morneau in the offseason. There was nothing to lose and he wasn't going to break the bank.

Community Moderator
Posted
I think he said Morneau would be his first realistic option.

 

I don't know if they can afford to play Ed every day at first.

Posted
I don't remember Lind being as bad as Smoak when he was here.

 

Lind had an incredibly bizarre career in Toronto. He had a great offensive year in 2009, then was below replacement level for three straight seasons, then became good again. Looking back on it I can't believe they gave him that much rope.

Posted
I don't know if they can afford to play Ed every day at first.

 

He should only not start one of the games that are day games after a night game.

Posted
I wanted the Jays to go after Morneau in the offseason. There was nothing to lose and he wasn't going to break the bank.

 

I wanted the same.

Posted

 

 

A torn ligament sounds really bad but I guess it's not. Could have only missed 4-5 games but with the 3-man bench they needed the extra roster spot. I can't wait for September with expanded rosters.

Posted
Lind had an incredibly bizarre career in Toronto. He had a great offensive year in 2009, then was below replacement level for three straight seasons, then became good again. Looking back on it I can't believe they gave him that much rope.

 

 

He was really just misused I think during the down years. He was always a well above average hitter vs RHP but couldn't touch a lefty, 2009 perhaps being the exception rather than the breaking point.

Community Moderator
Posted

 

 

A torn ligament sounds really bad but I guess it's not. Could have only missed 4-5 games but with the 3-man bench they needed the extra roster spot. I can't wait for September with expanded rosters.

 

if the ligament is torn it's more a case of whether he will make it worse or not if he plays and pain level. It takes months for a ligament to heal and it might need to be operated on to repair it. This is really bad if it's actually torn.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Blue Jays community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...