Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Should John Gibbons be retained for 2016?  

38 members have voted

  1. 1. Should John Gibbons be retained for 2016?

    • Yes
      14
    • No
      16
    • Only if Blue Jays win World Series
      8


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 2.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted (edited)
I've been shamelessly a Gibbons defender in the past, but holy f***. The moves he's made today and in the past few games are indefensible. Edited by Captain Adama
Posted
took 10 years but someone has finally passed Sam Mitchell as the worst to coach a Toronto sports team

Sam Mitchell isn't even the worst coach in raptors history. Get out.

Posted
I've been shamelessly a Gibbons defender in the past, but holy f***. The moves he's made today and in the past are indefensible.

 

I've defended him over and over, but I no longer can find any reason to continue doing so.

Posted
I've defended him over and over, but I no longer can find any reason to continue doing so.

 

I have never witnessed such incompetence from a manager in the postseason. Beyond comprehension.

Posted

Wow, seems my thread has taken off once some people opened their eyes lol.

 

Postseason history!!!!!! First position player ever to pitch. Great job Gibby lol

Posted
Wow, seems my thread has taken off once some people opened their eyes lol.

 

Postseason history!!!!!! First position player ever to pitch. Great job Gibby lol

 

lmfao

 

This was the worst managed game of the season and now you want to start patting your back? Yeah you can gtfo with that.

Posted
Babe Ruth pitched in the 1918 World Series :P

 

Broadcast said the first full time position player to pitch. I assume Ruth was still pitcher on occasion that year, haven't looked though.

Posted
Gibby wastes Price up 7 thinking the other team can come back, but will concede the game down 3 with the best offense in baseball. lol
Posted
Do any of you ppl have any clue what variance is?

 

Very much so.

 

Variance won't save us with the idiot we have as a manager.

Posted
Very much so.

 

Variance won't save us with the idiot we have as a manager.

 

Well evidently you don't by your post above

Posted
Well evidently you don't by your post above

 

It's not even a variance anymore, it has become the mean with Gibbons regarding poor bullpen management. Today it really, really came to a head.

Posted
Babe Ruth pitched in the 1918 World Series :P

 

wasn't he a still a pitcher at that point? Babe Ruth was a starter to begin his career so he wouldn't be considered an out and out position player.

Posted (edited)

He makes the correct decision more often then not, stop complaining over such a standard spot that simply went bad(lol variance).

 

Hawkins and Tepera are competent 7th bullpen arms, they had bad outings.

 

We did not lose this series over these decisions.

 

Shutup

Edited by tercet
learn 2 variance
Posted
It's not even a variance anymore, it has become the mean with Gibbons regarding poor bullpen management. Today it really, really came to a head.

 

we were in trouble no matter what because dIck went less than 2 innings. we don't have 7+ innings in our pen with everyone rested never mind with some guys having thrown yesterday.

Posted
we were in trouble no matter what because dIck went less than 2 innings. we don't have 7+ innings in our pen with everyone rested never mind with some guys having thrown yesterday.

 

 

Ty for having a brain unlike 95% of jays fans across Canada

Posted
That was unbelievable. You're down 3, bases loaded, none out. Your season hangs in the balance. And you bring in Ryan Tepera. No words.

 

I was so puzzled at the game today. Gibbons feels it's important to use Sanchez and Lowe with a 9-4 lead though in a close 3 run game he decides to turn to Hawkins and Tepera? I'm lost for words right now.

 

And Lowe is used instead in the 8th in a blowout when the game was far out of reach.

 

You're telling me losing 5-2 in the 7th and holding the score isn't as important as using Sanchez and Lowe with a 9-4 lead yesterday. Ugh

Posted
we were in trouble no matter what because dIck went less than 2 innings. we don't have 7+ innings in our pen with everyone rested never mind with some guys having thrown yesterday.

 

Well yeah I should've included yesterday in this as well. Using four relievers up by 7 runs is just as bad as his debacle today.

 

And yeah Dickey deserves no less blame in this either because of Gibby's shenanigans.

Posted
Yes, of course. But he played more games as a position player (only pitched in 20 games)... this trivia question depends on how you define "position player."

 

I'm pretty sure they said Pennington was the first out and out position player to pitch in post season. he'd never thrown a pitch professionally before....

 

back in the day (10s 20s-end of WWII) lots of pitchers played a position as well. they were just the best players on the team and were used as much as possible.

Posted
He makes the correct decision more often then not, stop complaining over such a standard spot that simply went bad(lol variance).

 

Hawkins and Tepera are competent 7th bullpen arms, they had bad outings.

 

We did not lose this series over these decisions.

 

Shutup

 

Jesus f***ing christ. This guy is saying we don't have brains?

 

Regarding decisions, how about the one to use four of our top relievers when we were up by 7 runs in the 8th and 9th innings?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Blue Jays community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...