Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Which wild card front office do you most believe in?  

97 members have voted

  1. 1. Which wild card front office do you most believe in?

    • Houston Astros (led by Jeff Luhnow)
      10
    • New York Yankees (led by Brian Cashman)
      4
    • Chicago Cubs (led by Theo & Jed)
      68
    • Pittsburgh Pirates (led by Neal Huntington)
      15


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 13.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
You think it is more to do with the player and less the character? FG writes have said for the last 2 months he will be traded and that it has to do with his makeup more than anything.

 

He's not saying that definitively, it's a combination of both, likely.

Posted
Puig for prospects would make a lot of sense right now.

 

Better flip those prospects for Trevor Plouffe though.

Posted

Buster Olney ‏

Keep hearing it from club execs: Ian Kennedy, who had a 4.28 ERA w/31 HRs allowed in 168 IP for SD in 2015, should take the qualifying offer

 

 

Adios Ian!!

Posted

Jeff Passan ‏

Braves listened on Andrelton Simmons last year, too. Talked an absolute blockbuster with Yankees that would've also included Justin Upton.

Posted
Buster Olney ‏

Keep hearing it from club execs: Ian Kennedy, who had a 4.28 ERA w/31 HRs allowed in 168 IP for SD in 2015, should take the qualifying offer

 

 

Adios Ian!!

 

I would think the players union should be pressing some of the borderline FA's to take the qualifying offer. Basically nobody accepts it so teams can offer it with impunity an expect a pick back. It would probably go a long away to keeping some players for being offered it if there was a precedent of it being accepted.

Posted
It doesn't help, sure, but Puig's batted ball numbers have been mediocre for a long time. I've been kinda nervous about him since he came up and still am.

 

Projected for 135 wRC+. I'll take the under.

 

f*** you

Posted
I would think the players union should be pressing some of the borderline FA's to take the qualifying offer. Basically nobody accepts it so teams can offer it with impunity an expect a pick back. It would probably go a long away to keeping some players for being offered it if there was a precedent of it being accepted.

 

Suddenly, Ian Kennedy looks much more desirable.

Posted
Jeff Passan ‏

Braves listened on Andrelton Simmons last year, too. Talked an absolute blockbuster with Yankees that would've also included Justin Upton.

 

Daaaaaamn

Posted
Daaaaaamn

 

Braves asked

Harvey or deGrom for Simmons

 

http://www.rotoworld.com/images/headshots/MLB/6780.jpg

 

 

 

According to Joel Sherman of the New York Post, the Mets checked in on the

availability of Andrelton Simmons on Thursday morning and were told that it

would take Matt Harvey or Jacob deGrom.

 

 

Yeah, so that's not happening. ESPN's Jonah Keri reported

Wednesday that the Braves have engaged in trade talks involving Simmons with at

least one National League West team, and Buster Olney added Thursday that the

Angels are also interested. Any team with a need at shortstop will be inquiring,

but it's going to take a sizable return for the Braves to give up the

26-year-old defensive maestro. He's on a relatively team-friendly contract

through 2020.

Posted
Braves asked

Harvey or deGrom for Simmons

 

http://www.rotoworld.com/images/headshots/MLB/6780.jpg

 

 

 

According to Joel Sherman of the New York Post, the Mets checked in on the

availability of Andrelton Simmons on Thursday morning and were told that it

would take Matt Harvey or Jacob deGrom.

 

 

Yeah, so that's not happening. ESPN's Jonah Keri reported

Wednesday that the Braves have engaged in trade talks involving Simmons with at

least one National League West team, and Buster Olney added Thursday that the

Angels are also interested. Any team with a need at shortstop will be inquiring,

but it's going to take a sizable return for the Braves to give up the

26-year-old defensive maestro. He's on a relatively team-friendly contract

through 2020.

 

Holy f***... huge price to pay.

Posted
Braves asked

Harvey or deGrom for Simmons

 

http://www.rotoworld.com/images/headshots/MLB/6780.jpg

 

 

 

According to Joel Sherman of the New York Post, the Mets checked in on the

availability of Andrelton Simmons on Thursday morning and were told that it

would take Matt Harvey or Jacob deGrom.

 

 

Yeah, so that's not happening. ESPN's Jonah Keri reported

Wednesday that the Braves have engaged in trade talks involving Simmons with at

least one National League West team, and Buster Olney added Thursday that the

Angels are also interested. Any team with a need at shortstop will be inquiring,

but it's going to take a sizable return for the Braves to give up the

26-year-old defensive maestro. He's on a relatively team-friendly contract

through 2020.

 

From a pure value standpoint, the Mets should probably at least consider Harvey for Simmons. With Simmons, you're basically looking at a 15 WAR floor for 53 million over the next 5 seasons, which works out to at least 70 million in surplus value. With Harvey, you're looking at about 13 WAR over 3 years and some really expensive arb salaries and not much hope of a long term deal with Scott Boras as the agent. There's also the injury concerns and pitcher volatility.

 

The fit is really nice for the Mets too with their pitching surplus and shortstop hole. I'd talk about it if I were Alderson.

Posted
Seems pretty fair to me IMO. I think if I'm the Mets, I pullthe trigger on Harvey for Simmons.

 

I don't understand why the Braves think they would be more competitive with Harvey than Simmons, especially during the window before Harvey gets extremely expensive and leaves in FA. I think Simmons is a bit overrated, but I just don't see how that benefits their particular situation.

Posted
I don't understand why the Braves think they would be more competitive with Harvey than Simmons, especially during the window before Harvey gets extremely expensive and leaves in FA. I think Simmons is a bit overrated, but I just don't see how that benefits their particular situation.

 

The Braves do a lot of things that don't make sense, but I guess they feel like Simmons is about to have a Bournian fall from grace.

Posted
The Braves do a lot of things that don't make sense, but I guess they feel like Simmons is about to have a Bournian fall from grace.

 

Which is somewhat understandable if you look at the career arc of their former prospect, Elvis Andrus. If Simmons loses a step he becomes much less attractive, since he's consistently a sub-.300 wOBA bat. Conversely, his defense is better than Andrus' ever was, and his contract is a lottttttt better.

Community Moderator
Posted
Simmons is scary as a long-term building block. As soon as he loses a step he's finished as an above-average player.
Community Moderator
Posted
Braves asked

Harvey or deGrom for Simmons

 

http://www.rotoworld.com/images/headshots/MLB/6780.jpg

 

 

 

According to Joel Sherman of the New York Post, the Mets checked in on the

availability of Andrelton Simmons on Thursday morning and were told that it

would take Matt Harvey or Jacob deGrom.

 

 

Yeah, so that's not happening. ESPN's Jonah Keri reported

Wednesday that the Braves have engaged in trade talks involving Simmons with at

least one National League West team, and Buster Olney added Thursday that the

Angels are also interested. Any team with a need at shortstop will be inquiring,

but it's going to take a sizable return for the Braves to give up the

26-year-old defensive maestro. He's on a relatively team-friendly contract

through 2020.

 

Scientific proof that defense is still a market inefficiency!

Community Moderator
Posted
Simmons is scary as a long-term building block. As soon as he loses a step he's finished as an above-average player.

 

He's a 26 year old generational defensive player. He could lose a dozen steps and still be a good defender.

 

He'll probably play shortstop until he's 40 and be pretty awesome at it almost until the end.

Posted
Rotoworld: Peter Gammons has heard from four different people that Aroldis Chapman will be traded by the end of the weekend.

 

Holy crap!

Posted
Rotoworld: Peter Gammons has heard from four different people that Aroldis Chapman will be traded by the end of the weekend.

 

Red Sox for Mookie Betts :)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Blue Jays community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...