I guess there's a glass half full or half empty way of looking at this trade. If you think Gimenez is a noodle bat, it's going to be underwhelming at best. But that's overlooking the ceiling he's shown (not potential, actual performance). At age 23, just two seasons ago, he produced a season as great as the very best ever by a Jays middle infielder. Right up there with Alomar's best seasons and better than Bo's very best year. He doesn't need to get all the way back to that level in order to produce surplus value. It's a risk- reward play that could actually turn out marvelously.