#57 was also worn by both Gary Carter (1974) and Randy Johnson (1988) for their debut stints with the Expos.
In terms of stars with longevity in the number, Johan Santana wore #57 for twelve seasons. I recall watching Doc outduel Santana on Opening Day when both were at their peak. That was 2006, after the Jays huge off season where we acquired Burnett, Glaus, Molina, Overbay and BJ Ryan.