You're conveniently ignoring the offense being worse than anticipated last year, it's not like the starters being better than expected meant it was a shock to make the playoffs. Nothing is guaranteed of course, but we had a good chance of making the playoffs.
Any Jays fan who watched that game will remember the bat flip for the rest of their life. I know I will!
Yes it was short term, yes it was a gamble, yes it would never have happened if AA's contract wasn't expiring. But it worked. We did make the playoffs 2 years in a row. We've still got a team that could contend to make the playoffs in the next 2 to 3 years (including this one) before Vlad, Bo etc make it here, without having to completely blow up the side. Even if you think we're not going to compete this year or next, we've got the assets to retool not rebuild.
Again, if the trades didn't happen we've have missed the playoffs, Shapiro and Atkins would almost certainly have gone full rebuild, and we'd be in the middle of a second 90-100 loss season in a row, and likely years away from competing, without any of those great memories from 2 playoff runs.
It was a big gamble under unique circumstances, that shouldn't be repeated, but it worked and to complain about it now is ignoring all the benefits we're still seeing now IMO.