Hey "Mr. Negativity" here to chime in on the fact that the Yankees are objectively a better team, and we have been lucky. Their run differential is miles ahead of us. We are 23-17 in one run games and they are 20-22. (Red Sox are 20-24)
Let me take you back to 2021, when everyone here talked about how we were clearly a better team because of our superior run differential and the Yankees and Red Sox were just lucky (I agreed by the way). They also had great records in one run games that year compared to our .500 record, it's the primary reason they finished ahead of us, but now that roles are reversed magically those things don't matter anymore?
Now I understand run differentials and one run games is not the end all and be all. I would even concede the Blue Jays might well be the second best team in the American League. Don't get me wrong, the Yankees are flawed: middle relief is wonky, the Stanton/Judge issue is definitely a problem, every team in the American League is flawed, but New York is still the best.
Doesn't mean we can't win the East or come out of the American League.