For every Kyle Gibson who's having a good year and providing lots of value for $10M, there is a list of other starters who have been f***ing terrible for $8M-$15M AAV range, including:
Andrew Heaney
Sean Manaea
Martín Pérez
Corey Kluber
Ross Stripling
Matthew Boyd
Noah Syndergaard
Mike Clevinger
Jordan Lyles
Jameson Taillon
Johnny Cueto
Zack Greinke
José Quintana
To be perfectly honest - almost every FA starter has sucked a bag of dicks this year as you can add Rodon and DeGrom to that list.
The FA pitchers having good years and providing value include:
Kershaw
Eflin
Walker
Eovaldi
Gibson
Senga
Bassitt
Smyly, Dick Mountain and Anderson are kinda of meh.
Given the uncertainty of Berrios and Kikucci this year, the Jays couldn't afford to "miss". Did they pay more to get someone like Bassitt with a better history of consistency and durability? I would say yes they did - but thank god they did. Are the O's some brilliant organization because they "hit" on Gibson? I don't think so - I think there's a ton of luck involved as lots of good organizations "missed" on their SPing FA signings this past season. Christ, the Rangers "hit" really well with Eovaldi, but missed on Heaney, DeGrom and Perez. They'd be incredible if the signed Eflin, Senga and Gibson instead of those 3.