The plus with Pillar, at least for this fan, is he'll get a ton of fastballs to hit, which he seems to feast on (don't have stats in front of me to underline this, though), and second, he can steal a base almost at will. He may have an OBP of .320, but a lot of those singles can be stretched a bit with the speed. But then again, with this offense behind him, does he need to steal? I think yes, stress out the defense of the opposition, force mistakes, and so on. Also, it'd allow Pillar to really develop that part of his game. Gain really good experience. But if he's not going to ever get the green light, then you may as well shove Tulo in the lead off position. Or anyone from 2-6, really.
I may have about seven too many commas in my reply above.