Gord Ash left Halladay, Carpenter, Escobar, Delgado, Wells, Rios, Hudson, Werth, etc,
Bad GM's make good moves. Unfortunately, if the bad is strong enough, it can outweigh the good. That's where AA stands. His last off-season was very good (Donaldson, Martin, Travis, Saunders) but it was outweighed by bad roster construction and keeping a manager that can't tell the difference between his best players and his worst.