You guys need to learn how to rate women independently of what your personal preferences are. This is the language of men, and it doesn't work if everybody is speaking a different language. The numeric component is supposed to represent the objective parts, such as physical health and fitness, proportional face, smooth complexion, symmetry, and maybe a natural-looking smile.
All the preferential stuff such as personality, character, hair/eye color, whether she likes video games, and so on, that's all great and important to talk about, but keep that s*** out of the zero-to-ten.