List of AA moves with big league implications..
2018
Kemp (1.6 WAR) to LA for Culberson (1.0 WAR), Gonzalez (N/A), Kazmir (N/A), McCarthy (0.2 WAR)
Signed Danny Santana (0.1)
Traded for Preston Tucker (0.0 WAR)
Signed Peter Bourjos (-0.1 WAR)
Signed Ryan Flaherty (-0.4 WAR)
Signed Jose Bautista (-0.1 WAR)
Traded international bonus money for Jonny Venters (0.2 WAR)
Traded for Adam Duvall (-0.5 WAR)
Traded international bonus money for Brad Brach (0.3 WAR)
Traded for Kevin Gausman (0.8 WAR, 10 starts)
That was his entire contribution to the 2018 Braves playoff team that won 90 games. Shatkins (or ShaCava) did more to help the 2016 Jays make the playoffs from a pure value standpoint of players they acquired/signed.
2019
Signed Josh Donaldson (3.3 WAR) ---> good move
Signed Brian McCann (1.0 WAR)
Signed Nick Markakis (0.2 WAR)
Signed Josh Tomlin (0.0 WAR, 59.1 IP)
Traded for Anthony Swarszak (0.1 WAR, 24 IP)
Signed Dallas Keuchel (0.4 WAR, 4.75 FIP, 56 IP)
Then his trade deadline moves that only have a week of sample size
If you prefer AA to Atkins, that is one thing. But if you say AA helped the Braves the last two years over practically anyone else who could have walked into that situation? Get the F out of here.
I'll give you the extensions. Smart moves by AA, even though taking advantage of dirt poor kids trying to support their families is not something I'd be too cool with, but hey it's not my life.