To put the Catching position in proper historical context, the greatest Catcher of all-time (Johnny Bench) has just 74.8 WAR. The best OFers have nearly 170.
And in MLB history, only 8 times has a Catcher put up an 8 WAR or better season. Buster Posey had the highest season ever at 9.8 WAR in 2012. Raleigh is on pace for 11 WAR right now.
But I suppose Judge's season is also historical. He's on pace to put up 12-13 WAR and that's only been accomplished by Bonds, Ruth and Gehrig.
But f*** Aaron Judge. He plays for the Yankees and I hope he gets hurt. I'd vote for Raleigh.