Playoff baseball is so much different than regular season. Kluber, Miller and Allen have thrown something like 60% of the Indians innings. That's tough to beat.
Didn't realize it was the 6th largest contract in history at the time. Those are pretty good points. You win. Luckily the Angels saved us and we only ended up paying about 60 million for 6.5 WAR. The Angels paid about 65 mil or so for 0.7 WAR.
But it's still incredibly risky IMO. 29-35 is a lot different than 33-40 or whatever it ends up being.
Well yeah Donaldson is better but that also means he'll cost a hell of a lot more. Remember that Wells only got an AAV of 18 mil a year. Donaldson is also older, and perhaps significantly so by the time a possible extension kicks in, than Wells ever was. The risk is perhaps even greater with Donaldson than it was with extending Wells for his age 29-35 seasons at 18 mil a year.
Yeah they aren't that comparable. I was just saying that all the posts seem to be pretty cautious when it seemed like OP's post seemed to be implying the opposite.
I don't think age of signing is comparable either. Wells' extension kicked in at age 29. Donaldson will be much older. Wells got a 126+ million dollar deal, Donaldson is looking at 200+. Donaldson is the better player, but that only means he'll be more expensive and since he's older it also means it's a bigger risk in a lot of ways.
I'd approach him now and ask him if he'd be interested in an extension. 7/200 or something like that. It'd be an immediate raise for him and he'd lock up a long-term fortune.
On the flip side, 31-37 could payoff for the Jays. 33-40 will almost assuredly not.
Last year was way worse. We had a really good team and a special second half of the year and the Royals BABIP'd us to a degree. I don't like the Royals either and they don't like us.
This year we sort of backed in to the Playoffs and then bitch slapped the O's and the Rangers. I was pretty well pleased by that point. On top of it the Indians just played well and I have no animosity toward that team at all. I like a lot of their players.
One thing to keep in mind regarding trading Estrada is that he's in the last year of his deal and could very well be a QO player after next season. He seems like he might be the right kind of player to accept a QO as well. Idk that's a long ways away but it's something to consider.
Castro would be money. He's only 29, is a very good pitch framer, and can hit right-handed pitching. He very would could outproduce Martin next season.
I'm glad you mentioned him. I see a lot of names thrown around for these corner OF spots and I'm not sure that all of them are better than a Pompey/Upton platoon.
He's coming off a good year. Arguably his best since 2013. I don't think he's really a buy-low kind of player. But if he came cheap I'd consider it. Decent defensively in LF and a decent bat. He's got some speed and hits righties well.
Nice summary of Atkins presser today by mlbtraderumors.com. Osuna not being stretched out, Biagini might be, and the Jays will look to potentially add “more balance, more platoon advantage and potentially more speed."
http://www.mlbtraderumors.com/
I think Liriano has some value. The 50 innings he pitched with the Jays were much much better than what he did with the Pirates and helped prove that he's still got something left in the tank. At the time we traded for him we risked trading for a guy that was perhaps pitching to his new talent level rather than going through a bad first half of the season. The 50 innings with the Jays help prove that it was more of the latter. Also, his one year deal isn't bad, the main problem with it being that you'd only get him for one season. But if you take a look at the FA market he'd be one of the top SP's available. We wouldn't get a big return for him but I think we could do better than what the Pirates did.
It's a double-edged sword. If Biagini is in AAA stretching out, and that's still an if, we have the 5 in MLB and then Biagini and Bolsinger as the #6 and #7. That's a great 1-5 and an ok 6-7 but we've got jack s*** after that. You trade one and we have even less. There also is hardly anything in FA so it'd be even harder to replace a traded SP.
But on the flip side you could probably get a shitload in a trade for JA Happ right now. The market for pitchers is historically bleak. Happ at 2 years 26 million is BY FAR anything better that you could get on the FA market. Shatkins might be able to get a serious overpay for someone like him.