Carroll was quite productive from 2010-2012 (2 WAR or higher). Still, Carroll should not be a target in the offseason, especially as a starting second baseman or as a utility player since the Jays already have Maicer. Carrying Goins, Carroll and Maicer all north of the border is just a complete waste and awful roster management. At least use that bench spot on a bat. I have no problem with Carroll on a minor league deal and he plays in Buffalo, though not on a MLB deal.