That's what makes this an interesting debate. I think each opinion (Sanchez or Stroman as No. 1) are both valid. I slightly place more value on prospects who are closer to the Majors and who could contribute right away more than a prospect who's 2-3 years away. Sanchez has the higher ceiling no doubt; though since Stroman could step in at anytime this season and contribute I'd vote him since he has a higher floor and still could attain No. 2-3 starter status.
I'd go with Stroman since he could make an impact this season at the MLB level; whereas Sanchez despite the higher ceiling comes with more risk and is still a year or 2 away.
OT question: in a 30-team dynasty league with salary cap, would you trade Jonothan Niese ($7.75 M until 2017) and Alexi Ogando (ARB 2017) for Billy Butler ($10.75 M? for 2014 and 15)? Thanks.
I think everyone on this board expected this team to win between 85-90 games. Its unfortunate how things played out; but if lets says Josh Johnson stayed healthy and pitched like his former self; Reyes didn't miss all that time; Melky played like he did in 2012; Dickey pitched like his second half; Bonafacio was at least half decent; Morrow was healthy and realized his potential - likely looking at a differ scenario. Still I'm not a fan of what this team has done since its backfired huge, though a lot of bad luck happened in 2013.
A lot of stuff needs to break right if this Jays team wants to contend. Basically a healthy Morrow who makes 30 starts would be huge; Lawrie staying healthy and having a breakout year; Rasmus building off his strong 2013; Dickey pitching like he did in the second half; someone like Stroman or Hutch step up during the season; Reyes stays healthy and plays 150 games; Melky plays like he did in 2012, and the list goes on. A lot to ask for, so I'm not getting my hopes up.
I have a great place for our next GM winter meetings for beer and food. I won't say on these boards, because I consider it Toronto's best kept secret haha
The 2008 pitching staff was amazing, though the lineup was terrible. For crying out loud, guys like Shannon Stewart, Kevin Mench, Brad Wilkerson got way too many AB's that season.