This is my team right now. I've made a lot moves since I took over the Blue Jays in September lol. I'm in a tough division though - both the Rays and Red Sox are pretty solid teams. The Rays even have Strasburg and Mike Trout ugh (don't ask me how that happened - the manager of the Angels is stupid haha).
Batters:
C: Salvador Perez (3.3M 2016 +++)
1B: Eric Hosmer (3.6M 2014, ARB 2017)
2B: Ian Kinsler (13.4M, 2017+)
SS: Ian Desmond (8.75M, 2015)
3B: Nick Castellanos - prospect
OF: Norichika Aoki 1.5M (2014)
OF: Curtis Granderson (8.1M, 2018)
OF: Junior Lake (0.5M 2016) (ARB 2017-2019)
DH: Billy Butler (10.25M, 2014 +)
BN: 2B Danny Espinosa (0.5M 2014, ARB 2017)
BN: Darin Ruf (0.5M, 2014)
Pitchers:
SP: Madison Bumgarner ($9.21M, 2017++)
SP: Mat Latos ($7.25M 2014, ARB 2015)
SP: Homer Bailey (Arb)
SP: Danny Salazar (0.5M 2014-2016) (ARB 2017-2019)
SP: Brandon Morrow (4.5M 2014+)
SP: Tim Hudson (5.25M 2015)
SP: Wily Peralta (0.5M 2014)
Bullpen:
RP: Sergio Santos (2.63M 2014+++)
RP: Drew Storen (3.45M 2014) (Arb 2016)
RP: Kelvin Herrera (0.5M)
RP: Dustin McGowan (2.75M 2014+)
RP: Jose Cisnero (0.5M 2014)
Disabled List:
DL: [sP] Daniel Hudson (0.5M 2014)
I know Castro can be frustrating, though even if he hits like he did in 2011 and 2012, that's still quite solid and I'd be happy. Tough call on what to do. I love Desmond and he's probably the No. 2 shortstop after Tulo in my opinion. Thanks!