It wouldn't be justified. A team with this young core and talent shouldn't be missing the Postseason by one or two games. It's unacceptable. The Blue Jays are never going to have a core with bats like Vladdy, Bo, Teo, Lourdes, Springer, Chapman, Kirk, and Jansen or a top rotation with Gausman, Berrios and Manoah every season for the next decade. Windows in baseball aren't open long. Players get injured, leave via free agency or trade, regress, and start becoming too expensive via arbitration or free agency. The Blue Jays have a two-three window for winning a World Series with this current core, lets be realistic.
You want to win a World Series with Vlad, Bo, and Manoah when they're under club control and not costing the club huge dollars. Once they start costing the Jays huge dollars after 2024 or 2025, will be difficult to address other areas on the roster.
I don't think most posters wanted Atkins to pillage the farm this trade deadline. We wanted him to make the roster upgrades that helped the Jays make the postseason. Like Terminator said, if the Jays suffer an injury to Gausman or Manoah, they'll have a huge uphill battle the rest of the way. The Blue Jays should not be missing the Postseason two seasons in a row with this core, especially with an extra team making it in this season. Every game counts and the Jays can't be throwing away games because they're starting a pitcher like Thomas Hatch for three or four games down the stretch.