Thought I'd evaluate catchers in the AL East, considering how tight the division is, to see who is the best in the division defensively and offensively.
Red Sox
Jarrod Saltalamacchia-- 0.0 dWAR, 1.3 oWAR
David Ross 0.4 dWAR, 0.2 oWAR (DL--concussion)
Ryan Lavarnway 0.0 dWAR, 0.1 oWAR
Good thing for Salty's bat--they're not paying him for his glove. David Ross's injury really hurts--it leaves them with two below average defensive catchers. Lavarnway's sample size is too small to determine. Salty ranks as one of the worst catchers in baseball defensively.. a tick below Arencibia. It should also be noted that most of the pitching last year for Boston that stunk was mostly Salty's fault.
YANKEES
Chris Stewart (0.3 dWAR, 0.1 oWAR)
Cervelli (0.7 oWAR, 0.2 dWAR)
Austin Romine (0.1 dWAR--don't ask about his offense)
Well, at least Yanks catchers can defend well--probably explains why their pitching has kept the team competitive.
ORIOLES
Matt Wieters 0.4 oWAR, -0.2dWAR
Teagarden (0.1 dWAR, -0.3 oWAR)
If Wieters is supposed to be a great catcher, why does he stink so much defensively this season? He's been far from a Gold Glover this year. Doesn't help that his pitching staff is 2nd worst in the AL, next to Houston.
RAYS
Jose Molina -0.2dWAR, 0.5 oWAR
Jose Lobaton 0.8 oWAR, 0.2 dWAR
Molina's losing a step--but Lobaton is doing well this season so far.
BLUE JAYS
JP Arencibia 0.7 oWAR, 0.1 dWAR
Thole (0.1 dWAR)
Blanco(DFA'd, only played when Dickey pitched, 0.0dWAR)
For defense in 2013--the best catchers are(as of present)
Yankees(0.6dWAR), Jays(0.1dWAR), Red Sox(0.4 with Ross, +-0.0dWAR without), Rays (0.0dWAR) Orioles(-0.1 dWAR).
If you're wondering how certain pitching staffs have done so well or so awful--look at their catchers. It usually matches up quite well--in order of ERA:
Yanks (4th), Red Sox(7th--still hard to call with Ross out), Jays (8th), Rays(12th), Orioles (14th)