I can't see Ohtani ever giving up on pitching, whether or not it might be the "right decision". He's just so f***ing good on the mound. Even if he has TJS again I would bet on him rehabbing and making another mound comeback attempt. I mean it's Verlander/Cole/Scherzer type stuff. He's also a good hitter and would probably be a really good full time outfielder, but that seems like the safer and lower upside route. I would not predict that bat Ohtani will ever really be a better offensive fantasy asset than we've already seen, which is a decent but frustrating UTIL player (barring a horrific arm injury that kills his pitching career entirely). In fact, when he's back on the bump I would guess that the Angels will actually limit his DH days even more than in 2018 while he was pitching, in an attempt to limit taxation on his body and prevent injuries.