Current pen:
Romano - good but not wholly proven and has had trouble staying healthy
Dolis - okay but not good this year, control problems, terrible viewing experience
Chatwood - unreliable and not performing recently
Castro - waiver claim, pitching fine but replacement level projections
Mayza - replacement level or close to it
Thornton - replacement level or close to it
Payamps - replacement level or worse
CEJ - replacement level or worse
Beasley - replacement level or worse
A complete nightmare. Probably one truly good reliever in the lot, maybe two or three if Dolis and Chatwood can right the ship.
Four of the team's five best RP are hurt. Two of them are definitely done for the year. Who knows if Merryweather and Borucki will return and stick.
At this rate, Pearson might be in the pen out of necessity in the second half.