That's actually a very interesting and relevant comparison.
TULO
2014
COL
MLB
29
91
375
21
71
52
1
13.3%
15.2%
.263
.355
.340
.432
.603
.444
170
0.2
29.8
5.6
5.1
2015
2 Tms
MLB
30
128
534
17
77
70
1
7.1%
21.3%
.160
.331
.280
.337
.440
.335
.320
101
-3.2
-2.4
8.5
2.4
2016
TOR
MLB
31
131
544
24
54
79
1
7.9%
18.6%
.189
.272
.254
.318
.443
.327
.351
104
-3.0
-0.3
4.7
2.3
2017
TOR
MLB
32
66
260
7
16
26
0
6.5%
15.4%
.129
.272
.249
.300
.378
.292
.289
79
-2.2
-8.8
2.5
0.2
2019
NYY
MLB
34
5
13
1
1
1
0
15.4%
30.8%
.364
.167
.182
.308
.545
.349
.292
119
0.0
0.3
-0.3
0.0
GEORGE
2021
TOR
MLB
31
78
342
22
59
50
4
10.8%
23.1%
.291
.286
.264
.352
.555
.381
.361
140
0.5
17.3
-2.8
2.6
2022
TOR
MLB
32
133
583
25
89
76
14
9.3%
17.2%
.205
.285
.267
.342
.472
.352
.342
133
4.5
25.9
-5.1
4.1
2023
TOR
MLB
33
154
683
21
87
72
20
8.8%
18.3%
.147
.291
.258
.327
.405
.320
.332
104
-0.4
2.6
-8.0
1.8
2024
TOR
MLB
34
145
614
19
74
56
16
9.8%
18.7%
.150
.245
.220
.303
.371
.298
.322
95
3.5
-0.1
-8.9
1.2
Tulo had a big offensive decline at age 30. The indicators were down. He struggled with health. He had a replacement level and injury riddled 2017 and Toronto released him with 2/$38M remaining on his contract after a 2018 that was lost to injury.
Tulo's xStats in 2017 were actually worse than his real stats. High chance of getting hurt again + decent chance of being cooked.
George Springer isn't there yet though. He had an okay .322 xwOBA in 2024. He does not have the injury risks. He still projects for above replacement level production. HOWEVER if he has a 2025, or half of a 2025, that resembles Tulowitzki's 2017, things could change.
But in 2024 the team clearly needs to be aggressive with role changes for him. He might reasonably end the season hitting in the bottom third of the order, or perhaps even as a bench or platoon player.
If you re-frame your thoughts of him and pretend he's a prospect, it's easy to see how he can still help most MLB teams. He's a good baserunner, he can cover an outfield corner, he has a bit of pop and speed is a 15/15 talent over a full season. Quality bench/platoon guy and maybe a second division starter on a bad team. 45 FV.