The Blue Jays have already gotten something like $3-4 million dollars in hypothetical value from Colabello. The trick will be to cut ties with him at the right time, so that he doesn't give that all back with a slump before getting DFA'd/demoted/traded/euthanized.
IIRC Juan Francisco was well over 1 fWAR at one point last year, but ended up at 0.8. He's the cautionary tale.
Month / PA / wOBA
Apr / 41 / .376
May / 85 / .432
Jun / 69 / .259
Jul / 69 / .367
Aug / 51 / .182
1st half: .359
2nd half: .251
With Colabello's extremely negative defensive value and PD stats, he could give back his 0.4 fWAR in like, one week of s***** play. Don't marry the guy.
Also his neck is too skinny and his head is too small and he sort of looks like a goomba.
5.8 BB%
24.7 K%
.169 ISO
.432 BABIP
Are these well and good projectable peripherals for a DH/1B? No...