Yes. I was wondering if better prospects would be better off facing 3 years of the best pitching under mlb that they can....
Hypothetically I wonder, would a player like Davis (or any other good prospect) be better off if every day, starting when they are 18, face the best pitching available, take reps using that pitching, instead of spending 2 or 3 years seeing mostly pitching they will never see at the level they hope to reach.
I think the feeling is that a young prospect will be overwhelmed by good pitching so young that it will break them.... or make them develop bad habits, or destroy their confidence... or maybe something else. I am not so sure.
I might be wrong, but I don't think there is anything that outrageous about asking the question.
With fielding it's not that hard to simulate. 19 and 20 yr olds can and do play mlb level defense (Anthony Gose). You can have hard hit ground balls (or fly) at you for hours and hours in practice and it can be very much what you will see at a major league level, thus you can master it early..... with hitting it's much harder. Even the best pitching machines don't come near simulating what you will see at the MLB level, they can throw hard and throw curves, but they can't simulate the angles or release points, thus making it much different. When you think about it, the actual in game experience of hitting lasts only a few minutes a game and only a few seconds when you consider the time the pitcher throws to when it reaches the batter..... It's not a lot of practice time.
I wonder if teams are looking into robotics for a machine that can better simulate mlb pitching.... I don't know.