Steamer600
Horwitz - 2.2 fWAR
Gimenez - 3.0 fWAR
I know Gimenez has that one monster season, and Toronto is probably projecting Gimenez to be a bit better than that, but a) I don't trust Toronto's evaluation of hitters, and We're talking about a $93M commitment for Gimenez while Horwitz will make the minimum for two more years.
I really don't like this deal.
We could have had:
Horwitz
Josh Rojas (~4M)
Kirby Yates/David Robertson/some other good FA reliever (12M)
$77M
but instead we have Andres Gimenez
I just hate the idea of paying sticker price for defense. I feel like good teams find those kinds of players for cheap. 15.2M is a big chunk of the available budget, and I'm not sure 2B defense should have been the priority. Maybe I'm misreading the market on someone like Josh Rojas, but I'm guessing he doesn't get more than IKF last year, costs nothing via trade, and probably puts up 2+ WAR if you run him out there every day.
Who cares about Jordan Romano? He's a 32-year old reliever who just missed like 80% of the year with an elbow issue that hasn't been repaired. You can give the same money to Chris Martin or something.
Crowdsourced Fangraphs projection was 1/8 lol. Top guys like Scott, Estevez and Hoffman are going to be close to 40M probably. This is the place to wait and try to nab guys like Martin, Sewald, Romano, Yates, Robertson on 1-year deals.
Not even just the 1 mediocre season. His last really good season was the short 2020 season. Conforto is such a limited player. Really bad defender even on a corner spot. Below-average runner. Has to sit against tough lefties. Doesn't mash righties like Pederson who has a similar skill set.