OK, so here's where I stand:
J4L19, L54, and Greenwood have offered commentary on the decision, and I trust all three of you, so I think you three should decide what to do about this (and spittin should he read this). I've stated my opinions, and have nothing further to add to the discussion.
I'm not putting myself though this again though, so I ask that any amendment to the decisions made come with a new rule to eliminate subjective decisions of this nature going forward. We'll put into place whatever you three decide by consensus.