I know people are leery about making new threads and others hate the huge Around Baseball thread. So we'll throw everything in here. If you feel a trade is thread worthy, go ahead and make it. A mod might throw it in here or keep it. Don't fear making threads at this point in the season. If you start making a thread cause a thought popped in your head, you might get a warning email.
Anyway Indians have added Lucroy and Miller in exchange for Frazier, Sheffield, Mejia, Allen and Chang.
What I like about it: Indians added two talents players both of whom are under control for this year and next (Miller and the rest of the core for 2 seasons). They had the deepest system in baseball. They still have some pieces on the farm. This was not a full AA type all-in as the entire core is under control.
What I don't like about it: They were 86% to win the division, 95% to make the playoffs...they could have traded the same prospects in the off season and did even better (or kept them). The playoffs are still a crapshoot and while this improved their team it's not like it writes them a ticket to the finals.