With all the Shapiro love, let's look at his picks as a GM from 2001-2010.
Out of all his draft picks in ten years, unless I missed some, here are his best picks:
Chris Archer
Jason Kipnis
Drew Pomeranz
Cody Allen
Jeremy Guthrie
Luke Scott
Kevin Kouzmanoff
Have I missed anyone else?
Here is what AA drafted in his first three years alone. That includes 2012, where we still don't even know what some of the other guys will turn into. His highest draft is #11 overall, then #17 overall.
Noah Syndergaard
Marcus Stroman
Aaron Sanchez
Daniel Norris
Kevin Pillar
Anthony DeSclafani
Sam Dyson
Dalton Pompey
Alford
In ten years Shapiro drafted four above average players.