Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Community Moderator
Posted
53 minutes ago, Laika said:

2.2 WAR projection

Crowd source was 3/$51M 

QO free agent so Boston loses pick

Interesting roster for Boston. Contreras / Bauers / Anthony / Yoshida something's gotta give. Also Casas' corpse. 

Milwaukee was NEVER going to commit that money to a 1B/DH 

Bauers/Contreras pretty much every day at 1B/DH

Anthony, Rafaela, Abreu, Duran in the OF

Duran probably could be had for almost free to anyone willing to pay him 11M in arb. He was terrible last year, projects poorly, and might be the biggest douche in the league. But he’s also a capable CF and a year removed from putting up 11 WAR over a two year stretch, available on a 1-year commitment, and controllable for two seasons.

Posted
2 hours ago, BTS said:

Bauers/Contreras pretty much every day at 1B/DH

Anthony, Rafaela, Abreu, Duran in the OF

Duran probably could be had for almost free to anyone willing to pay him 11M in arb. He was terrible last year, projects poorly, and might be the biggest douche in the league. But he’s also a capable CF and a year removed from putting up 11 WAR over a two year stretch, available on a 1-year commitment, and controllable for two seasons.

Duran would be a nice buy low. 

 

Posted
4 hours ago, BTS said:

Duran probably could be had for almost free to anyone willing to pay him 11M in arb. He was terrible last year, projects poorly, and might be the biggest douche in the league.

I cracked up, it's likely true.

Posted

I was reading through the 14 newcomers to the HOF ballot on MLB.com, Kyle Seager carved out a pretty decent stretch their back in the day...

Seager put together a 6.3-WAR season in 2014, the year of his lone All-Star selection and Gold Glove. He hit 25 homers and had a 127 OPS+ that summer. He followed that up with 5.3 WAR in 2015 and 6.9 WAR in ‘16. Only Mike Trout and Josh Donaldson had more WAR than Seager’s 18.5 over that three-year period. 

Posted
12 hours ago, Spanky__99 said:

I was reading through the 14 newcomers to the HOF ballot on MLB.com, Kyle Seager carved out a pretty decent stretch their back in the day...

Seager put together a 6.3-WAR season in 2014, the year of his lone All-Star selection and Gold Glove. He hit 25 homers and had a 127 OPS+ that summer. He followed that up with 5.3 WAR in 2015 and 6.9 WAR in ‘16. Only Mike Trout and Josh Donaldson had more WAR than Seager’s 18.5 over that three-year period. 

Definitely had a nice stretch during that time. It's too bad his career ended early at 33. 

Posted
45 minutes ago, BTS said:

If I'm voting:

Lester

Posey

Abreu

Buehrle

Hamels

Hernandez

Pettitte

A-Rod

Rollins

Utley 

 

wow

Posted
19 hours ago, Spanky__99 said:

Here's the full list of the Ballot...  https://www.mlb.com/news/baseball-hall-of-fame-ballot-2027

How do we embed tweets from x on here now, since they changed that process, I haven't a clue?  

@Brock Beauchamp 👆

uo2Lc.png

You should be able to paste the URL to the tweet, and it should automatically embed. If it doesn't right away, hit the spacebar, that sometimes triggers it.

Community Moderator
Posted
2 hours ago, Brownie19 said:

For sure:

Abreu

King Felix

Pettitte

A-Rod

Utley

David Wright

Posey

I need to think about it more:

Rollins

Buehrle

Hamels

Lester

Francisco Rodriguez

Wright should be in, but would be my 11th choice on the current ballot. 

K-Rod is interesting. He has a case:

- 6th most saves of all-time

- one of 16 players with 1000+ K's in relief 

- only RP ever with 60+ saves in a season 

- dominant run in the Angels 2002 WS season 

 

I think I'd probably fall just short of voting for him, but he might be the best reliever that I think isn't HoF eligible. 

Posted

You're all letting too many dudes in 

David Wright had like, two or three superstar seasons. No MVPs, no playoff resume. 

Yes if he was healthy he probably gets in on volume WAR and would have been a 12 time all star or whatever. But that reality did not happen. 

Felix Hernandez is in the same boat. If you are letting these guys in then why don't you also have Pedroia on your ballot?

Posey gets the unique catcher arguments and I would perhaps vote for him, but I also think Russell Martin should get the same arguments and he did not and sadly didn't even stay on the ballot for more than one year.

 

 

I would personally only be voting for Utley and A-Rod, and I guess probably Posey. Utley just had an insane peak and gets over the line for me. A-Rod is a legend and I don't personally believe people should be kept out due to steroid use - perhaps if they were borderline but A-Rod would have had a HOF career without roids... I am a small hall guy for the most part and am not sure I would vote for Pettitte or Hamels or Abreu or any others. 

Posted

I agree that Wright, K-Rod, etc. shouldn't even sniff the Hall.

Utley and A-Rod are the only obvious one for me. I also would vote for Pettitte and I am on the fence with Abreu. Neither had very high peaks but both had really good longevity. 

Abreu had close to a .400 OBP for his career and 59.7 WAR. He's only a 2x All-Star and 1 GG so he doesn't have much hardware and zero postseason accolades. He also gets absolutely hammered for his defense. Was he really that bad? Idk and that's why I'm on the fence with him.

Pettitte had 68 WAR which in itself makes a pretty strong case. He was only a 3x All-Star and he finished Top 5 in CY voting 4 times. He did win 5 World Series and threw 276 playoff innings with a 3.81 ERA. 68 WAR along with all the postseason stuff is enough.

Posted

I am most certainly biased by the memories of watching some of these guys.  Wright was one of my favourite players.  Him and King Felix were 50 WAR players in careers that essentially ended at age 30 due to injury (at least Wright's was due to a debilitating injury).

The HOF let f*cking Harold Baines in.  By that measure, almost everyone who played 15+ years is a HOFer.  I'm not willing to go that far, but I am willing to let a few more fringe players in if I think they helped form the history of the game for their era.

Community Moderator
Posted

Big Hall is more fun! 

I think going forward any SP over 50 WAR will basically be a slam dunk. Going to start with Felix then include Wheeler, DeGrom, and Cole 

Posted
24 minutes ago, Laika said:

David Bednaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa accepted the QO 

You love to see it. Nobody wants to pay a reliever $23.5 million. He can be this year's Trent Grisham. 

 

Yeah he might be good but the Yanks are apparently cash strapped and that's a huge bite out of their payroll for just one RP. He'll cost more than our entire bullpen this year.

Posted
1 hour ago, Laika said:

David Bednaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa accepted the QO 

You love to see it. Nobody wants to pay a reliever $23.5 million. He can be this year's Trent Grisham. 

I thought it was odd that the Yankees qualified Bednar and not Chisolm. Bednar seemed like a near lock to accept it at above average market rate and Chisolm seemed like he wouldn't accept it given the likelihood of receiving sufficient offers in free agency to turn it down. 

Posted
16 minutes ago, max silver said:

I thought it was odd that the Yankees qualified Bednar and not Chisolm. Bednar seemed like a near lock to accept it at above average market rate and Chisolm seemed like he wouldn't accept it given the likelihood of receiving sufficient offers in free agency to turn it down. 

The Trent Grisham thing just completely broke them as an organization 

They will never make a correct QO decision again 

Posted
35 minutes ago, Laika said:

The Trent Grisham thing just completely broke them as an organization 

They will never make a correct QO decision again 

I thought the Grisham qualifying offer was semi defensible as he produced a very nice season with the bat and the underlying data suggested he was actually a little bit unlucky results wise. It looked like this was possibly a breakout season but the improvements certainly didn't prove to be durable.

Posted
6 hours ago, Laika said:

So you guys are putting players like Cutch and Longoria in, first ballot, as well? I guess?

I own a Longoria jersey and a signed ball by him too.  So I vote him in 😁

That's a fair question.  They are close for me and I agree that they have a lot of similarities to some of the people I'd support going into the hall.  I guess I'd have to say yes for consistency.  I'm not thrilled by that, but I could live with it.  I really enjoyed watching both of their careers.  Longoria was so good in his prime with Tampa.  Leading that broke ass team deep into the playoffs in 2008 as a 22 year old.  He had 6 HRs and they always seemed in critical moments.  

Posted

King Felix definitely deserves to get in at some point. He dominated for 6 years straight of 5 + WAR seasons from 2009-2014, and pretty much was a workhorse during his prime. He also came onto the scene back in 2005 as a 19-year-old and had some solid seasons as well.  

One of my favourite pitchers back in the day. He threw me a ball from the dugout in Toronto back in 2009 after I was cheering AL Cy Young at him after he looked up haha. 

Posted

I just wanted to say that all the major Toronto sports teams suck balls.  Raps and Leafs have combined to lose the last 11 games at the ACC.  Just horrendous efforts.  Following the Jays 5th place finish in the AL East and it seems like all our teams are struggling to meet expectations.  Brutal times!  The question is - which team will turn it around first?  Jays, Leafs or the Raps?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Blue Jays community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...