Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Old-Timey Member
Posted
He failed a test but it was one of those tests that was done before the new PED policy as a way to gauge how rampant PEDs were. It was never supposed to be release but it was leaked anyway.

 

So he can't go to the Hall.

  • Replies 803
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
This is not the place to bring in Grili. I don't want a guy who walks a ton of guys and gives up a ton of flyballs pitching to this team in this park.

 

You are aware that Osuna and Estrada are both extreme flyball guys, yes?

Posted
Hope Dickey is cracking a beer now then hitting the cold shower.

 

I trust Dickey more than I trust our 7th inning options right now.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
I trust Dickey more than I trust our 7th inning options right now.

 

Wow that's like taking your chances in traffic.

Posted
Your pro Dickey fanboyism is gbill Barry Davis like.

 

My position is that he is a reasonably paid backend starter and should be extended at a reasonable price. On this board since everyone finds him annoying that counts as "fanboyism." He's pitching a decent game and still getting s*** on that's how much he's hated.

 

 

You can't ever even argue on his talent - just outside s*** like he's "annoying" or we gave up too much in a trade. Now you're restorting to calling me a fanboy because you can't really argue anything else.

Posted
So he can't go to the Hall.

 

As a DH with PED test pos in same Era as all the others not in who should be, it will be very difficult for Papi.

Posted
So he can't go to the Hall.

 

He's a DH who failed a drug test and was worse than Edgar Martinez but for some reason I see him getting in to the HOF anyway.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
My position is that he is a reasonably paid backend starter and should be extended at a reasonable price. On this board since everyone finds him annoying that counts as "fanboyism." He's pitching a decent game and still getting s*** on that's how much he's hated.

 

 

You can't ever even argue on his talent - just outside s*** like he's "annoying" or we gave up too much in a trade. Now you're restorting to calling me a fanboy because you can't really argue anything else.

 

5BB and 3K through 6 is terrible.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
As a DH with PED test pos in same Era as all the others not in who should be, it will be very difficult for Papi.

 

If Barry Bonds isn't a hall of famer Ortiz can't be either. Bonds was an all-around player as well.

Posted
5BB and 3K through 6 is terrible.

 

How is that relevant at all to what I just posted? lol

 

I said he's a decent backend SP and you pull 6 innings worth of stats? Are you saying that proves that he's not a solid backend SP?

Old-Timey Member
Posted
How is that relevant at all to what I just posted? lol

 

I said he's a decent backend SP and you pull 6 innings worth of stats? Are you saying that proves that he's not a solid backend SP?

 

"He's pitching a decent game and still getting s*** on that's how much he's hated."

Posted
"He's pitching a decent game and still getting s*** on that's how much he's hated."

 

Oh woops yeah you're right. Yeah that's terrible but he's getting a lot of soft contact. I think you could argue it's a decent game.

Posted
Not a good at-bat. We need a big hit from Edwin.

 

He is getting a steady diet away and of course Edwin pulls it into a GB to SS.

Community Moderator
Posted
My position is that he is a reasonably paid backend starter and should be extended at a reasonable price. On this board since everyone finds him annoying that counts as "fanboyism." He's pitching a decent game and still getting s*** on that's how much he's hated.

 

 

You can't ever even argue on his talent - just outside s*** like he's "annoying" or we gave up too much in a trade. Now you're restorting to calling me a fanboy because you can't really argue anything else.

 

I didn't mean disrespect, was just worked up.

 

Look, I understand where you're coming from but I think a guy like Hutchison could give us very similar results at a fraction of the price. Pass balls are a thing with Dickey, hell that's how they scored today. That's a real negative aspect to his game. A walk, pass ball and a double is often how he implodes. He demands the shittiest catcher in the league, I miss Navarro as a backup and prefer him as an Estrada personal catcher anyday to this combo. It's not just that he's annoying, that's an obvious factor but the s*** that comes with it for just a 5th starter should be unnecessary in this league

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Blue Jays community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...