Forum Top Prospects

[King]

No I am not. I just don't like him...people are allowed to just not like someone, has nothing to do with race.

 

Why do you not like McCutchen? He's a legitimate superstar player in his prime on a good contract for the next 3 years.

 

This is absurd.

[jays_fever]

``I just dont like him``

 

Best argument ever

[Jimcanuck]

No I am not. I just don't like him...people are allowed to just not like someone, has nothing to do with race.

 

What has he done that makes you not like him? The hair?

[BTS]

No I am not. I just don't like him...people are allowed to just not like someone, has nothing to do with race.

 

I bet you also think Barry Bonds was a bit of a jerk. I wonder why?

[Daniel Labude]

Why do you not like McCutchen? He's a legitimate superstar player in his prime on a good contract for the next 3 years.

 

This is absurd.

 

I dont know for sure. He is a great player. Just something about him annoys me. When I have seen him play it just looks like at times he is going half speed. Amazing player though, defense and offense.

[Daniel Labude]

I bet you also think Barry Bonds was a bit of a jerk. I wonder why?

 

I loved Bonds. Wanted the Jays to sign him the year he got screwed by mlb.

[Jimcanuck]

I dont know for sure. He is a great player. Just something about him annoys me. When I have seen him play it just looks like at times he is going half speed. Amazing player though, defense and offense.

 

Are there other players in baseball that annoy you?

[BTS]

Are there other players in baseball that annoy you?

 

I've seen him post that he doesn't like Ortiz or Sabathia.

[Daniel Labude]

Are there other players in baseball that annoy you?

 

Yeah, why?

[Jimcanuck]

Yeah, why?

 

Looking for commonality.

 

You know, there's a saying 'don't judge a book by its cover'

[Grant77]

I wouldn't mind giving my opinion on these lists, I was on them a few years ago.

 

You still follow the minor leagues closely? I recall you making positive contributions in the other lists, for sure.

[Daniel Labude]

Looking for commonality.

 

You know, there's a saying 'don't judge a book by its cover'

 

Harper, Buehrle, Puig, Volquez, Pierzynski, Gardner, and Jeter to name a few.

[Orgfiller]

I've seen him post that he doesn't like Ortiz or Sabathia.

 

I heard he's not very fond of Ben Revere or Rajai Davis either.

[Orgfiller]

Harper, Buehrle, Puig, Volquez, Pierzynski, Gardner, and Jeter to name a few.

 

Wtf? Reported

[L54]

Harper, Buehrle, Puig, Volquez, Pierzynski, Gardner, and Jeter to name a few.

 

Would you have traded Big Hoff for Harper?

[Daniel Labude]

Would you have traded Big Hoff for Harper?

 

After the season Harper just had...most likely. Before last season probably not, cause we needed pitching.

[Jimcanuck]

After the season Harper just had...most likely. Before last season probably not, cause we needed pitching.

 

How old are you?

[Daniel Labude]

How old are you?

 

?, are we really going to get into these debates again. Pitching and defense will win championships.

[43211234]

I wouldn't mind being added if there's still room.

[Daniel Labude]

Before the season, would you have traded Hoffman for both Harper and Trout?

 

Yes

[Daniel Labude]

If you were the Mariners, would you trade Felix Hernandez and James Paxton for Mike Trout, Bryce Harper and Buster Posey?

 

Yes...all these combinations will probably be a yes.

[Daniel Labude]

If you were the Mariners, would you trade Felix Hernandez and James Paxton for Mike Trout, Bryce Harper and Buster Posey?

 

Before last season would you trade Hoffman for Trout knowing there was no chance to win it all or trade Hoffman for Greinke knowing you had the best chance to win it all.

[Orgfiller]

Before last season would you trade Hoffman for Trout knowing there was no chance to win it all or trade Hoffman for Greinke knowing you had the best chance to win it all.

 

Lol @ Trout not giving your team the better chance over Greinke. Use common sense dude.

 

There's also the fact that Trout is on a team friendly contract and all of 24 years old, while Greinke was becoming a FA at the end of the season. Trout adds much more to your team over the remainder of his contract than a year of Greinke.

 

What a ridiculous suggestion.

[BTS]

Before last season would you trade Hoffman for Trout knowing there was no chance to win it all or trade Hoffman for Greinke knowing you had the best chance to win it all.

 

Trout. You could always trade him for like Kershaw plus LA's prospects.

[L54]

Before last season would you trade Hoffman for Trout knowing there was no chance to win it all or trade Hoffman for Greinke knowing you had the best chance to win it all.

 

Sometimes you can appear more intelligent admitting when you're wrong instead of sticking to your guns through and through.

[Daniel Labude]

Lol @ Trout not giving your team the better chance over Greinke. Use common sense dude.

 

Sadly I am, you are not. Pitching owns hitting in the playoffs. If we had Greinke, Price, Stroman, Estrada in the playoffs with our offense...compared to the pitching we had and Trout instead of Pillar.

[Daniel Labude]

Trout. You could always trade him for like Kershaw plus LA's prospects.

 

That's reasonable.

[jays_fever]

The team that just won the world series had a very average starting staff but okay

[Orgfiller]

Sadly I am, you are not. Pitching owns hitting in the playoffs. If we had Greinke, Price, Stroman, Estrada in the playoffs with our offense...compared to the pitching we had and Trout instead of Pillar.

 

Then why didn't the Mets win the WS with their far superior rotation compared to the Royals?

[bendera3]

Sadly I am, you are not. Pitching owns hitting in the playoffs. If we had Greinke, Price, Stroman, Estrada in the playoffs with our offense...compared to the pitching we had and Trout instead of Pillar.

 

Price did awesome in the playoffs.