Awful Carrasco Trade Ideas Thread

[Jimcanuck]

It'd be pretty close. I just prefer the position player to pitcher in terms of long term control. If they each had say 2 or 3 years of control then I would do it.

 

not close at all.....

[burlingtonbandit]

Walker is 22-23, has been a top prospect for years and has top of the rotation stuff. Pillar just had one very good season at age 26. I don't think it's close at all but to each their own.

 

Meant it'd be a close call for me personally. I don't think Seattle would accept it.

[Angrioter]

Walker for Pillar lol

[Jimcanuck]

Walker for Pillar lol

 

i know eh? no way Jays do that

[Angrioter]

i know eh? no way Jays do that

 

Young controlable stud with big ceiling for a 2 Wins CF 26 years old?

[Frenchsoup]

Young controlable stud with big ceiling for a 2 Wins CF 26 years old?

 

You mean young controllable 4 win stud CF to patrol that huge outfield in Seattle, for a 23yr old who is a huge flyball pitcher with piss poor mechanics and timing. Yeah Seattle pulls the trigger on that easy.

[L54]

You mean young controllable 4 win stud CF to patrol that huge outfield in Seattle, for a 23yr old who is a huge flyball pitcher with piss poor mechanics and timing. Yeah Seattle pulls the trigger on that easy.

 

Care to wager on the 4 WAR part?

[Frenchsoup]

Care to wager on the 4 WAR part?

 

I would yes, with a clause that if he hits 5 WAR you double it so say 20 bucks for the 4 WAR part and if he hits 5 you owe me 40?

[thatoneguy]

Can we stop talk about trading Tulo in this thread? The Indians have Lindor anyway so it wouldn't really be relevant to talk about involving him in a deal for Carrasco (or to any other team because who are the Jays reasonably going to get that's better at SS).

[GD]

I would yes, with a clause that if he hits 5 WAR you double it so say 20 bucks for the 4 WAR part and if he hits 5 you owe me 40?

 

I'll do that if 54 doesn't

[L54]

I would yes, with a clause that if he hits 5 WAR you double it so say 20 bucks for the 4 WAR part and if he hits 5 you owe me 40?

 

And if he's under 3 you owe me 40?

[Frenchsoup]

I'd have to put in PA's minimum as well, say 550?

[King]

http://www.bluejaysmessageboard.com/threads/65-Official-Board-Wagers-Thread?p=807714#post807714

[Frenchsoup]

And if he's under 3 you owe me 40?

 

Nah

[King]

lol

[L54]

Nah

 

So the wager is $20 then. O/U 4 WAR with a 550 PA threshold?

[GD]

Nah

 

Under 2.5 = $40 makes it a fair bet

[Jimcanuck]

young controlable stud with big ceiling for a 2 wins cf 26 years old?

 

your sarcasm detector is broken

[reedjohnsonfan]

You mean young controllable 4 win stud CF to patrol that huge outfield in Seattle, for a 23yr old who is a huge flyball pitcher with piss poor mechanics and timing. Yeah Seattle pulls the trigger on that easy.

 

Troll post or terrible post, not sure

[Spanky99]

I probably wouldn't even do Walker for Pillar.

 

Wat? Seattle would tell LaCava to f*** off, regardless.

[Spanky99]

It'd be pretty close. I just prefer the position player to pitcher in terms of long term control. If they each had say 2 or 3 years of control then I would do it.

 

No, no it isn't. Walker has potential, top rotation value, you're huffing glue.

Edited November 12, 2015 by Spanky99

[Spanky99]

Can we stop talk about trading Tulo in this thread? The Indians have Lindor anyway so it wouldn't really be relevant to talk about involving him in a deal for Carrasco (or to any other team because who are the Jays reasonably going to get that's better at SS).

 

It is the awful Carrasco trade idea thread...

 

Just turned into the awful trade Pillar to Seattle thread.

[Cyborg]

Pillar + for Carrasco!

[Dr. Dinger]

Pillar + for Carrasco!

 

Lol that would be a wet dream.

[Laika]

Ugh I want any one of Kluber/Carrasco/Salazar so god damn bad

 

I'll be gutted if the Yankees land one of them.

[Angrioter]

Pillar + for Carrasco!

You are on drugs, bro

[Dr. Dinger]

Ugh I want any one of Kluber/Carrasco/Salazar so god damn bad

 

I'll be gutted if the Yankees land one of them.

 

Especially if Brett Gardner is the headline return piece.

[Angrioter]

Especially if Brett Gardner is the headline return piece.

Gardner+ for Carrasco and I will cry...

[THANOS]

Pompey for Bauer?

 

Possibly, or maybe it's a mega package for Carrasco/Salazar? They were specifically named earlier in the Gardner rumour.

[burlingtonbandit]

Possibly, or maybe it's a mega package for Carrasco/Salazar? They were specifically named earlier in the Gardner rumour.

 

Possibly but I can't see the Jays selling the farm for Carrasco with Shapiro aboard.