Official Fantasy Baseball Advice Thread

[Spanky__99]

Redraft lmao... what a tire fire.

[connorp]

Redraft lmao... what a tire fire.

 

Concentrate of finding some good deals on motorized wheelchairs. Check Amazon first

[connorp]

If I was in a board fantasy league and Jim offered me J-Rod for Greene, I’d tell him “your time passed, my friend”.

 

Cease and Clase reunited me with Greene and Royce last month.

[FantasyNewb]

What about Dylan Crews and Basallo for Trout?

[L54]

What about Dylan Crews and Basallo for Trout?

 

Probably should do that. Guys aren’t hitting the ground running from the minors to the bigs anymore.

 

You have a good strategy. Pick up minor leaguers and trade them for good big leaguers. Surprised your league mates haven’t caught on yet

[FantasyNewb]

Probably should do that. Guys aren’t hitting the ground running from the minors to the bigs anymore.

 

You have a good strategy. Pick up minor leaguers and trade them for good big leaguers. Surprised your league mates haven’t caught on yet

 

Yeah, the strategy is working well. Thanks.

[connorp]

Vlad for Casas, Mayer, and Baz.

 

Pretty fair? Or could I ask for one more piece? I’d be offering Vlad

[BTS]

Vlad for Casas, Mayer, and Baz.

 

Pretty fair? Or could I ask for one more piece? I’d be offering Vlad

 

If this isn't a league of Jays fans that's probably not going to get accepted

[L54]

Doubt I’d do Vlad for Casas alone at this point

[Terminator]

I'm in a 14 team dynasty where you can pick up minor leaguers midseason. I have one slot available and maybe more depending on what happens over the course of the year. The top guys I've identified are:

 

-Luis Morales OAK

-Blake Mitchell KCR

-Travis Sykora WAS

-Max Muncy OAK

-Cooper Pratt MIL

-Angel Genoa CLE

 

I'm generally not that big on pitching and catching prospects but the alternatives are guys much lower on lists like Pratt or Genoa.

 

Who would you guys take?

[Laika]

They all suck, surely you can find better dudes

 

Try harder

[Stangstag]

I'm in a 14 team dynasty where you can pick up minor leaguers midseason. I have one slot available and maybe more depending on what happens over the course of the year. The top guys I've identified are:

 

-Luis Morales OAK

-Blake Mitchell KCR

-Travis Sykora WAS

-Max Muncy OAK

-Cooper Pratt MIL

-Angel Genoa CLE

 

I'm generally not that big on pitching and catching prospects but the alternatives are guys much lower on lists like Pratt or Genoa.

 

Who would you guys take?

 

I like the power that Mitchell is showing as a 19 yr-old, but the K rate could be a problem.

[Terminator]

I like the power that Mitchell is showing as a 19 yr-old, but the K rate could be a problem.

 

Thank you! Given the slop I'm choosing from I think that's as good of a reason as any.

[MikeM3]

I'm in a 14 team dynasty where you can pick up minor leaguers midseason. I have one slot available and maybe more depending on what happens over the course of the year. The top guys I've identified are:

 

-Luis Morales OAK

-Blake Mitchell KCR

-Travis Sykora WAS

-Max Muncy OAK

-Cooper Pratt MIL

-Angel Genoa CLE

 

I'm generally not that big on pitching and catching prospects but the alternatives are guys much lower on lists like Pratt or Genoa.

 

Who would you guys take?

 

Loudest tools and projection = Morales or Pratt

[Daniel Labude]

I'm in a 14 team dynasty where you can pick up minor leaguers midseason. I have one slot available and maybe more depending on what happens over the course of the year. The top guys I've identified are:

 

-Luis Morales OAK

-Blake Mitchell KCR

-Travis Sykora WAS

-Max Muncy OAK

-Cooper Pratt MIL

-Angel Genoa CLE

 

I'm generally not that big on pitching and catching prospects but the alternatives are guys much lower on lists like Pratt or Genoa.

 

Who would you guys take?

 

Sykora

[Terminator]

Loudest tools and projection = Morales or Pratt

 

I went with Morales for my next pickup, thanks.

[Terminator]

Sykora

 

Going to go with him or Pratt next. Can probably pick up both by season's end. Thank you.

[jaysblue]

Playoffs in a 20-team dynasty, and you have to keep one: Camilo Doval or Daniel Hudson?

[BTS]

Playoffs in a 20-team dynasty, and you have to keep one: Camilo Doval or Daniel Hudson?

 

With the way Doval is pitching, he seems unlikley to get you a save or hold ROS. And might blow up your K/BB in a low leverage appearance. And pitches for a team with fewer chances at holds/saves.

[FantasyNewb]

I can only protect 8 of the following pitchers in my dynasty league:

 

Cease

Gilbert

Fried

Crochet

Berrios

Baz

Woo

Eury Perez

Lodolo

Jackson Jobe

Rhett Loweder

Noah Schultz

 

Which 4 would you cut?

[BTS]

I can only protect 8 of the following pitchers in my dynasty league:

 

Cease

Gilbert

Fried

Crochet

Berrios

Baz

Woo

Eury Perez

Lodolo

Jackson Jobe

Rhett Loweder

Noah Schultz

 

Which 4 would you cut?

 

Berrios

Lodolo

Lowder

Jobe

[Laika]

I can only protect 8 of the following pitchers in my dynasty league:

 

Cease

Gilbert

Fried

Crochet

Berrios

Baz

Woo

Eury Perez

Lodolo

Jackson Jobe

Rhett Loweder

Noah Schultz

 

Which 4 would you cut?

 

Mostly agree with BTS. You can just find new prospects so don't get attached to Jobe, Lowder, Schultz. Berrios is an obvious cut here.

[Terminator]

Chris Sale wins the Cy Young award.

 

On behalf of the board, I would like to APOLOGIZE (see, it's not that hard if you're a real man) to jaysblue for telling him to drop Sale for fantasy purposes.

 

I can't remember who we told you to pick up instead, but I'm pretty sure it was a scrub. Sorry pal, we done goofed.

[jaysblue]

Chris Sale wins the Cy Young award.

 

On behalf of the board, I would like to APOLOGIZE (see, it's not that hard if you're a real man) to jaysblue for telling him to drop Sale for fantasy purposes.

 

I can't remember who we told you to pick up instead, but I'm pretty sure it was a scrub. Sorry pal, we done goofed.

 

I came on the board asking if I should trade Bellinger for Chris Sale during the 2023 season and everyone said yes. Was regretting it at the end of the 2023 season after Belly's hot finish, but after Sale's Cy Young 2024 season, I'm happy to have made the trade since I kept Sale and his Cy Young season was extremely valuable to the overall success of my roster, more than Bellinger would have been.

 

So if I cursed you guys for giving me bad advice on that one, my bad.

[jaysblue]

Skenes is not that good

 

Laika definitely takes this back haha.

[Terminator]

I came on the board asking if I should trade Bellinger for Chris Sale during the 2023 season and everyone said yes. Was regretting it at the end of the 2023 season after Belly's hot finish, but after Sale's Cy Young 2024 season, I'm happy to have made the trade since I kept Sale and his Cy Young season was extremely valuable to the overall success of my roster, more than Bellinger would have been.

 

So if I cursed you guys for giving me bad advice on that one, my bad.

 

Oh wait so we gave you good advice? Apology retracted.

[jaysblue]

Oh wait so we gave you good advice? Apology retracted.

 

Retracted apology accepted.

[Spanky__99]

My “son” traded him Darvish and Painter in BORED for Seager as well

 

lmao

[BTS]

Terminator and I haven't gloated nearly enough about beating Jim et al. in last offseason's Cody Bellinger wars

[Jimcanuck]

So Jim et al won 2023 and you f***ing *******s won 2024