Official Fantasy Baseball Advice Thread

[connorp]

I feel this way about Andrew Vaughn after dealing with all you f***wads

[Laika]

The market determines the value. In a 20 teamer, I would have no interest, unless rebuilding. 30 teamer I would give up a late 2nd for him.

 

Manoah might be this year's Berrios of last year, though.

 

Berrios had a 4.21 xFIP last year and a FIP above replacement level. Not even close. Not the same planet of underperformance.

[Spanky__99]

I know I'm not selling low on Manoah, lol @ a 4th.

[Jimcanuck]

Berrios had a 4.21 xFIP last year and a FIP above replacement level. Not even close. Not the same planet of underperformance.

 

Of course. My point is Manoah could turn it around between now and next April.

Edited July 19, 2023 by Jimcanuck

[Laika]

Yeah but "turn it around" probably just means he's a 1 WAR SP.

[Jimcanuck]

Yeah but "turn it around" probably just means he's a 1 WAR SP.

 

Beginning of the year he was on some Cy Young candidate lists

[connorp]

Beginning of the year he was on some Cy Young candidate lists

 

Don’t fuel his fire about casuals

[Jimcanuck]

Don’t fuel his fire about casuals

 

Why not have some fun?

[connorp]

Why not have some fun?

 

Well, the clairvoyance he thinks he has didn’t help him properly analyze the Varsho deal, so it’s a wash

[Laika]

Nobody knows everything, it's baseball.

 

I'll be right 60% of the time and you dorks will be right 40% of the time.

[Terminator]

What's Manoah's value in a 20-team dynasty league?

 

I think the most realistic scenario for him is he contributes nothing this year and is a #4 SP next year. That's not worth much in a 20 teamer.

 

But the outcomes for him are pretty wild. He could be a #2 again or he could be out of the league.

 

It would depend on the keeper/roster rules exactly, but I'd move him for a 1st. 2nd would make me think. Anything less than that and I'd rather keep him around to see if he rebounds next year.

[connorp]

Nobody knows everything, it's baseball.

 

I'll be right 60% of the time and you dorks will be right 40% of the time.

 

Tom Tango rubbed off on you. Unless you’re on in the same of course

[Laika]

Tom Tango did not rub any part of me who told you that

[Spanky__99]

Haha. Losers. Meanwhile Andrew Painter will win ROY entering the season at 19

 

Painter needing TJS looks good on you, feel sorry for the kid though.

[connorp]

Painter needing TJS looks good on you, feel sorry for the kid though.

 

Yeah, bad for baseball. And I don’t hate BTS. So nothing to enjoy with it

[connorp]

Seager for Busch and Painter isn’t something one would take right now though. Time will tell

[connorp]

My “son” traded him Darvish and Painter in BORED for Seager as well

[jaysblue]

A lot of you baseball geniuses don't know anything.

 

Since I traded Cody Bellinger, he's been one of the best hitters in baseball. Now I'm stuck with an aging and injured lefty in Chris Sale.

 

Don't take fantasy baseball advice from the BJMB geniuses on here.

 

Haha just joking. But damn since I traded Bellinger I'm regretting it now.

[L54]

You didn’t have to trade him

 

Hitters > pitchers

[connorp]

I think I’d cash in my chips now on Belly if I could. I’m not saying I’m Term level, but there will likely be some rollercoastering. There’s prob decent offers to be had rn

[connorp]

Same for Yelich

[Jimcanuck]

A lot of you baseball geniuses don't know anything.

 

Since I traded Cody Bellinger, he's been one of the best hitters in baseball. Now I'm stuck with an aging and injured lefty in Chris Sale.

 

Don't take fantasy baseball advice from the BJMB geniuses on here.

 

Haha just joking. But damn since I traded Bellinger I'm regretting it now.

 

Need names. I doubt I advised moving Bellinger for Sale.

[Spanky__99]

Need names. I doubt I advised moving Bellinger for Sale.

 

He's too chicken too, for some odd reason...

 

https://www.bluejaysmessageboard.com/threads/2929-Official-Fantasy-Baseball-Advice-Thread?p=1716195&viewfull=1#post1716195

[Spanky__99]

I think I’d cash in my chips now on Belly if I could. I’m not saying I’m Term level, but there will likely be some rollercoastering. There’s prob decent offers to be had rn

 

That's why Jim is trying to sell... you and him are cut from the same cloth, snake oil salesmen.

[connorp]

That's why Jim is trying to sell... you and him are cut from the same cloth, snake oil salesmen.

 

I like off board newbs as much as I like real life 90 Day fiancé chicks. The remaining ones in bbdl can’t be swindled though. Seemingly

[jaysblue]

He's too chicken too, for some odd reason...

 

https://www.bluejaysmessageboard.com/threads/2929-Official-Fantasy-Baseball-Advice-Thread?p=1716195&viewfull=1#post1716195

 

I wish you got Sale before I did haha

[Jimcanuck]

He's too chicken too, for some odd reason...

 

https://www.bluejaysmessageboard.com/threads/2929-Official-Fantasy-Baseball-Advice-Thread?p=1716195&viewfull=1#post1716195

 

So he shouldn't pay attention to what BTS says.

[jaysblue]

I can't believe I'm coming back here for advice after that disastrous Bellinger/Sale trade.

 

In a 20 team dynasty league, who would you take: OF Kerry Carpenter or SP Dane Dunning?

[Jimcanuck]

I can't believe I'm coming back here for advice after that disastrous Bellinger/Sale trade.

 

In a 20 team dynasty league, who would you take: OF Kerry Carpenter or SP Dane Dunning?

 

Possibly neither

[Laika]

Yeah neither long term

 

Short term, team need