Official Fantasy Baseball Advice Thread

[BTS]

H2H Dynasty

 

I have Woodruff. Offer is Taj Bradley, Gavin Stone, Cade Horton

 

or I could take only two of Harrison/Bradley/Stone

 

So one deal I get three, other just two.

 

I have space for lots of specs.

 

I am leaning one way. What say you?

 

I'm keeping the ace. Probably only one of those arms pan out, and not to the level of Woodruff.

[connorp]

Arozarena

 

Baty

Tyler Gentry

2nd round pick/ high

 

No discussion?

[jays4life19]

Arozarena

 

Baty

Tyler Gentry

2nd round pick/ high

 

No discussion?

 

We feel we have a contending team so trading one of our best hitters for prospects and picks is not something we are looking to do.

[connorp]

Take him off the trade block, cock teases

[connorp]

Now that I’m public, I’m looking for mlb player in BORED, if anyone is down

[Laika]

Arozarena

 

Baty

Tyler Gentry

2nd round pick/ high

 

No discussion?

 

Dogshit offer

[connorp]

Dogshit offer

 

I think Gentry was a 1st round pick in bbdl. Sneaky good

also your opinion on Baty has been noted before. Won’t be the last, or even 1000th time, that you’ve been wrong

[Laika]

I don't hate Brett Baty

 

You just keep trying to trade him for bona fide fantasy studs and it's hilarious

[connorp]

I downgraded to Springer, let’s see

[L54]

I think Gentry was a 1st round pick in bbdl. Sneaky good

also your opinion on Baty has been noted before. Won’t be the last, or even 1000th time, that you’ve been wrong

 

BBDL draft position isn’t a very good barometer

[connorp]

Let me edit the record before Jim (or Spanky) does, he was a 4th round pick for Jim lol

[Stangstag]

I downgraded to Springer, let’s see

 

Pass

[connorp]

Ha. I was just going to cancel it anyway. Just sitting around bored (pun) on a Sunday trying to make a trade

[Stangstag]

Ha. I was just going to cancel it anyway. Just sitting around bored (pun) on a Sunday trying to make a trade

 

Tbh it seemed pretty decent for both of us, but like I said before im trying to compete this year somewhat.

 

I’ll reevaluate after a couple months and see where im at, might be willing to move Springer or even Judge at that point. If not then probably after the season.

[L54]

Tbh it seemed pretty decent for both of us, but like I said before im trying to compete this year somewhat.

 

I’ll reevaluate after a couple months and see where im at, might be willing to move Springer or even Judge at that point. If not then probably after the season.

 

If you move Judge I’ll make you an offer

[Stangstag]

If you move Judge I’ll make you an offer

 

Won’t be til midseason at earliest but i’ll keep you in mind

[Spanky99]

Won’t be til midseason at earliest but i’ll keep you in mind

 

You keep everyone in mind, lol.

[Spanky99]

We feel we have a contending team so trading one of our best hitters for prospects and picks is not something we are looking to do.

 

lol @ connor

[The Cats Ass]

I don't hate Brett Baty

 

You just keep trying to trade him for bona fide fantasy studs and it's hilarious

 

Ya, but he's pairing him with a 2nd round pick and a fringe dime dozen type prospect.

[The Cats Ass]

Tbh it seemed pretty decent for both of us, but like I said before im trying to compete this year somewhat.

 

I’ll reevaluate after a couple months and see where im at, might be willing to move Springer or even Judge at that point. If not then probably after the season.

 

It probably wasn't, CP won't give you fair value. Make sure to shop players around before moving them in this league.

[connorp]

Ya, but he's pairing him with a 2nd round pick and a fringe dime dozen type prospect.

 

Try to be objective. After ST, Baty is probably a Top 15 prospect to-date. Pair that with a #20-25 overall milb pick, what exactly do you think should be added for a very good, but aging and injury prone corner OF

 

An intriguing prospect like Gentry, at the same position, would be very fair. I can respect he’s not going to retool though

[Stangstag]

You keep everyone in mind, lol.

 

You guys are the most important people in my life

[Spanky99]

You guys are the most important people in my life

 

[The Cats Ass]

Try to be objective. After ST, Baty is probably a Top 15 prospect to-date. Pair that with a #20-25 overall milb pick, what exactly do you think should be added for a very good, but aging and injury prone corner OF

 

An intriguing prospect like Gentry, at the same position, would be very fair. I can respect he’s not going to retool though

 

You should probably take your own advice. Would you move L Robert for a package of Marcelo Mayer, 2nd Rounder, and Bryce Elder?

[Stangstag]

You should probably take your own advice. Would you move L Robert for a package of Marcelo Mayer, 2nd Rounder, and Bryce Elder?

 

Bryce Elder is sneaky good

[The Cats Ass]

Bryce Elder is sneaky good

 

Was hoping he'd win a rotation job. Elder > Gentry

 

It was tough finding a Gentry comparison on my team. Maybe Bubba Thompson would have been a better example? Tough picking my fringe roster guys. If prospect porn had an awards ceremony my team would be the attendees.

[Stangstag]

Was hoping he'd win a rotation job. Elder > Gentry

 

It was tough finding a Gentry comparison on my team. Maybe Bubba Thompson would have been a better example? Tough picking my fringe roster guys. If prospect porn had an awards ceremony my team would be the attendees.

 

I was just kidding honestly

[connorp]

You should probably take your own advice. Would you move L Robert for a package of Marcelo Mayer, 2nd Rounder, and Bryce Elder?

 

Luis Robert is a Top 20 dynasty asset, amigo. Springer is 34yo this year. It was a clear overpay actually

[connorp]

I traded for Rendon a couple years ago when he was more valuable than Springer now, for Baty (further away/lower value) and Adames while struggling with TB

One of my worst moves

[The Cats Ass]

Luis Robert is a Top 20 dynasty asset, amigo. Springer is 34yo this year. It was a clear overpay actually

 

Robert = Arozarena. Only spot he's top 20 is in your head.

 

That package for Springer is getting closer to fair. But the 2nd/3rd pieces should be better.