Official Fantasy Baseball Advice Thread

[canadiansportsjunkie]

np

 

Why are you trying to trade your entire roster for his entire roster?

 

It's basically Harper plus a few guys who have little value for Buster, Yelich and depth upgrades. However he has a few other good pieces I might get involved...Do you enjoy trying to be a dick? Because I know in the real world your not.

 

16 teams and Brad Hand and RA Dickey are actually being rostered?

 

Holds are a stat. He is putting up decent numbers he is currently in my stream spot but i have held onto him longer then usual. Dickey will be most likely dropped this week but for sure someone will pick him up...

[GD]

It's basically Harper plus a few guys who have little value for Buster, Yelich and depth upgrades. However he has a few other good pieces I might get involved...Do you enjoy trying to be a dick? Because I know in the real world your not.

 

Yes, I am. I mean you seem like you know it's a good deal, so.

[Boxcar]

It's basically Harper plus a few guys who have little value for Buster, Yelich and depth upgrades. However he has a few other good pieces I might get involved...Do you enjoy trying to be a dick? Because I know in the real world your not.

 

 

 

Holds are a stat. He is putting up decent numbers he is currently in my stream spot but i have held onto him longer then usual. Dickey will be most likely dropped this week but for sure someone will pick him up...

 

So he had an RP instead of Posey? I'm sure he wont mind that very minor change.

[canadiansportsjunkie]

Highly doubt that.

 

Never said it was a good deal. Actually I rejected the trade but wanted to see if anyone else had any thoughts on a new deal.

[canadiansportsjunkie]

So he had an RP instead of Posey? I'm sure he wont mind that very minor change.

 

Typical 1st offer trying to buy low

on Harper.

[L54]

Keep Harper.

[crazy47larry]

Keep Harper. The worst time to trade him is now. Don't sell low on him in a keeper league like that.

[jaysblue]

I was offered this in one of the 20 team dynasty leagues I'm in on ESPN.

 

I trade: J.T. Realmuto and Jeremy Jeffress

I receive: Eric Hosmer & Tony Barnette

 

Currently my 1B options are Chris Carter, Travis Shaw, and Profar has 1B eligibility as well. Have Ortiz and Morales as well, though they only have UTL. As for my catchers, I have Willson Contreras and Tyler Flowers, so its not like Realmuto was my starter in the first place.

[canadiansportsjunkie]

i would do that deal

[Boxcar]

I was offered this in one of the 20 team dynasty leagues I'm in on ESPN.

 

I trade: J.T. Realmuto and Jeremy Jeffress

I receive: Eric Hosmer & Tony Barnette

 

Currently my 1B options are Chris Carter, Travis Shaw, and Profar has 1B eligibility as well. Have Ortiz and Morales as well, though they only have UTL. As for my catchers, I have Willson Contreras and Tyler Flowers, so its not like Realmuto was my starter in the first place.

 

Lol for real? Obvious yes.

[GD]

That's such a gross deal. Everyone involved is so icky. But ye

[crazy47larry]

I was offered this in one of the 20 team dynasty leagues I'm in on ESPN.

 

I trade: J.T. Realmuto and Jeremy Jeffress

I receive: Eric Hosmer & Tony Barnette

 

Currently my 1B options are Chris Carter, Travis Shaw, and Profar has 1B eligibility as well. Have Ortiz and Morales as well, though they only have UTL. As for my catchers, I have Willson Contreras and Tyler Flowers, so its not like Realmuto was my starter in the first place.

 

hosmer side wins

[jays4life19]

Hosmer kinda sucks but yeah do it.

[jaysblue]

In a 30-team salary cap dynasty league, would you trade Manny Machado straight up for Mike Trout?

[z3r0s]

f*** yeah

[jaysblue]

f*** yeah

 

Yeah I'd be getting Mike Trout. I figure Machado as a FA will get over 30M anyways, so salary wise it's going to end up being a wash, unless Trout cracks 40M after 2020. Only downside is the position eligibility, but Trout offensively is the far superior player.

[z3r0s]

Manny is a beast, yeah he's going to get paid too. I feel like it will be a while before we see a 40M player, even Trout.

 

Thing about Trout is that he's so f***ing consistent. I also think you're going to get more SB's out of him than Manny will.

[Orgfiller]

In a 30-team salary cap dynasty league, would you trade Manny Machado straight up for Mike Trout?

 

Is this even a real question?

[jays_fever]

Yeah I'd be getting Mike Trout. I figure Machado as a FA will get over 30M anyways, so salary wise it's going to end up being a wash, unless Trout cracks 40M after 2020. Only downside is the position eligibility, but Trout offensively is the far superior player.

 

Is that the really stupid TPB league? Is the Brewers owners still running his team into the ground and trying to veto every other trade?

[jays4life19]

9 team league with traditional 5x5 cats (but OBP instead of AVG).

 

Trea Turner for Bumgarner? yay or nay?

[John_Havok]

9 team league with traditional 5x5 cats (but OBP instead of AVG).

 

Trea Turner for Bumgarner? yay or nay?

 

What's the rest of your roster look like?

 

And 9 Teams? Everyone will have an all star team anyways

[Laika]

9 team league with traditional 5x5 cats (but OBP instead of AVG).

 

Trea Turner for Bumgarner? yay or nay?

 

Turner

[Boxcar]

9 team league with traditional 5x5 cats (but OBP instead of AVG).

 

Trea Turner for Bumgarner? yay or nay?

 

I'd take Turner.

[jays4life19]

What's the rest of your roster look like?

 

And 9 Teams? Everyone will have an all star team anyways

 

C- Willson Contreras, ChC C, OF

1B- Paul Goldschmidt, Ari 1B

2B- Trea Turner, Wsh 2B, OF

3B- Kyle Seager, Sea 3B

SS- Troy Tulowitzki, Tor SS

OF- Yoenis Cespedes, NYM OF

OF- Kyle Schwarber, ChC

OF- Christian Yelich, Mia OF

UT- Joey Votto, Cin 1B

 

Bench: David Dahl, Ben Zobrist and Justin Turner (lol f***ing 9 team leagues)

 

Pitching: Darvish, Hendricks, Duffy, Rich Hill, Salazar, Tallion, Rodon, Sam Dyson, Greg Holland and Koda Glover (min 1800 innings pitched)

[AdamGreenwood]

Got a trade offer in a different league. Mulling it over. Hmmmm...

 

James Paxton

Yasiel Puig

 

for

 

Harrison Bader

Blake Rutherford

[Orgfiller]

Got a trade offer in a different league. Mulling it over. Hmmmm...

 

James Paxton

Yasiel Puig

 

for

 

Harrison Bader

Blake Rutherford

Is this a real question?

[P2F]

http://i2.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/001/115/949/d0d.jpg

[Abomination]

Got a trade offer in a different league. Mulling it over. Hmmmm...

 

James Paxton

Yasiel Puig

 

for

 

Harrison Bader

Blake Rutherford

 

Trade offers worthy of blocking a person's email address are always fun. Send them a comparable one in return.

[jays4life19]

Drop Kyle Hendricks in a 9 man league?

[Laika]

Drop Kyle Hendricks in a 9 man league?

 

And add who? (probably)