Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted

I won't say who they should take. It's pretty simple for me, take the BPA. I don't care who it is, this pick HAS to turn out to be a good one as this is a very important draft.

 

It would be great if whomever it is moves quickly through the system, but as long as they get a heck of a player, I'm fine with it. If it's a bust, I'll rip this FO.

  • Replies 601
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Old-Timey Member
Posted
If we take a bat, I hope we end up taking someone who profiles as a guy who can make contact, instead of these 4 tool players who do everything but hit. What do guys like Meadows and Peterson appear like as contact makers?
Posted
If we take a bat, I hope we end up taking someone who profiles as a guy who can make contact, instead of these 4 tool players who do everything but hit. What do guys like Meadows and Peterson appear like as contact makers?

 

I know Peterson can definitely hit and make contact, that's all he's done in college, however, that's all he can do, and if he can't hit very well at the majors, he's utterly useless.

 

From the video I've seem from Meadows (the All-America ones on Youtube), he's got a bit of a long swing and apparently he does swing and miss a lot, Frazier has better bat speed.

Posted
If we take a bat, I hope we end up taking someone who profiles as a guy who can make contact, instead of these 4 tool players who do everything but hit. What do guys like Meadows and Peterson appear like as contact makers?

 

Toolsy OF, looking for the next Mike Trout (Jake Anderson, Dwight Smith, Crouse, Hawkins)

Community Moderator
Posted

Seems kind of nuts that Frazier might actually be in the picture at #10.

 

He'll probably get popped at #9 by Pitt, just like Giolito got popped at #16 by the Nats last year.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
Seems kind of nuts that Frazier might actually be in the picture at #10.

 

He'll probably get popped at #9 by Pitt, just like Giolito got popped at #16 by the Nats last year.

 

Oh my God you had to bring that up. That was so painful.

Community Moderator
Posted

You know they would've passed on Giolito anyway.

 

I had a weird ass dream last night. My girlfriend was the Blue Jays GM, and we made the 10th overall pick at an A&W drive through. She wanted to pick someone I'd never heard of, and I was all mad about it, so we drove off and later found out that the scouting director picked Trey Ball. Then she turned into a chicken and the GM office flooded with two inches of water and the door wouldn't open. So the chicken GM girlfriend had to walk on it's tippy toes and it's chicken feet got all water logged and wrinkly. And Tinnish kept swimming down to slide paper under the door, because he wanted to keep the GM in the loop. And this happened in a school for some reason and there was a bike club which I was more concerned with than anything.

Posted
Seems kind of nuts that Frazier might actually be in the picture at #10.

 

He'll probably get popped at #9 by Pitt, just like Giolito got popped at #16 by the Nats last year.

 

I can't believe that Frazier is projected to be selected out of the top 5. I'd love if the Jays could grab Frazier at #10, his elite bat speed is exactly what this system needs. It probably takes the BoSox selecting a pitcher and the Pirates taking McGuire.

Community Moderator
Posted
I can't believe that Frazier is projected to be selected out of the top 5. I'd love if the Jays could grab Frazier at #10, his elite bat speed is exactly what this system needs. It probably takes the BoSox selecting a pitcher and the Pirates taking McGuire.

 

And it seems like him and Meadows are falling down draft boards together. I thought these guys were virtual locks for top ~6 selections.

Posted
And it seems like him and Meadows are falling down draft boards together. I thought these guys were virtual locks for top ~6 selections.

 

It looks like there will definitely be a high upside guy that's slipped available to the Jays. I just hope AA goes BPA and not the safe route with another Blue Jays classic Romero/McGuire/Jenkins selection.

Posted
It looks like there will definitely be a high upside guy that's slipped available to the Jays. I just hope AA goes BPA and not the safe route with another Blue Jays classic Romero/McGuire/Jenkins selection.

 

add our #1 pick Jake Anderson (Beede f*** you)

Old-Timey Member
Posted
I know Peterson can definitely hit and make contact, that's all he's done in college, however, that's all he can do, and if he can't hit very well at the majors, he's utterly useless.

 

From the video I've seem from Meadows (the All-America ones on Youtube), he's got a bit of a long swing and apparently he does swing and miss a lot, Frazier has better bat speed.

 

Meadows does look like he has a long swing and his hands seem to move a fair bit but he looks like he has the ability to develop a smooth line drive swing. That and what looks to be plus speed (tripled down the LF line in one of the videos I saw).

Posted
I think i would rather go for Ball, seems to have better secondaries and command, the fastball isn't as good but i could see Ball adding some velo pretty easily

 

I would take Manaea cause he could help right away and I think have a Chris Sale like impact. My only concern is his Scott Boras connection. Seeing as we're "going for it" I think we should make the exception in his case. I mean Manaea is "struggling" this year and he still has a 1.47era and 93 strikeouts in 73innings. I think once he's healthy you're going to see that velocity back in the 94-96 range instead of 92-94. He's a potential top of the rotation starter. Ball has as much upside as anyone, but in comparison you're going to have to wait 5-6 years.

Posted (edited)
I would take Manaea cause he could help right away and I think have a Chris Sale like impact. My only concern is his Scott Boras connection. Seeing as we're "going for it" I think we should make the exception in his case. I mean Manaea is "struggling" this year and he still has a 1.47era and 93 strikeouts in 73innings. I think once he's healthy you're going to see that velocity back in the 94-96 range instead of 92-94. He's a potential top of the rotation starter. Ball has as much upside as anyone, but in comparison you're going to have to wait 5-6 years.

 

I'm fine with them taking a college player as long as they are taking the BPA.

Edited by theblujay
Old-Timey Member
Posted
You know they would've passed on Giolito anyway.

 

I had a weird ass dream last night. My girlfriend was the Blue Jays GM, and we made the 10th overall pick at an A&W drive through. She wanted to pick someone I'd never heard of, and I was all mad about it, so we drove off and later found out that the scouting director picked Trey Ball. Then she turned into a chicken and the GM office flooded with two inches of water and the door wouldn't open. So the chicken GM girlfriend had to walk on it's tippy toes and it's chicken feet got all water logged and wrinkly. And Tinnish kept swimming down to slide paper under the door, because he wanted to keep the GM in the loop. And this happened in a school for some reason and there was a bike club which I was more concerned with than anything.

 

A.) Yeah, I heard he wasn't even on their draft board, there was a quote like that. Dumn.

 

B.) http://cdn.memegenerator.net/instances/250x250/37981500.jpg

Posted
I had a weird ass dream last night. My girlfriend was the Blue Jays GM, and we made the 10th overall pick at an A&W drive through. She wanted to pick someone I'd never heard of, and I was all mad about it, so we drove off and later found out that the scouting director picked Trey Ball. Then she turned into a chicken and the GM office flooded with two inches of water and the door wouldn't open. So the chicken GM girlfriend had to walk on it's tippy toes and it's chicken feet got all water logged and wrinkly. And Tinnish kept swimming down to slide paper under the door, because he wanted to keep the GM in the loop. And this happened in a school for some reason and there was a bike club which I was more concerned with than anything.

 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lurasidone

 

In clinical studies, lurasidone alleviates positive symptoms (e.g., hallucinations, delusions) without inducing extrapyramidal side effects except for akathisia.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
And it seems like him and Meadows are falling down draft boards together. I thought these guys were virtual locks for top ~6 selections.

 

People way overreact to small sample sizes in the draft. It only takes a few games for a guy to rocket back up the board which is kind of stupid when you're investing in a guy for almost 10 years.

Posted
You know they would've passed on Giolito anyway.

 

I had a weird ass dream last night. My girlfriend was the Blue Jays GM, and we made the 10th overall pick at an A&W drive through. She wanted to pick someone I'd never heard of, and I was all mad about it, so we drove off and later found out that the scouting director picked Trey Ball. Then she turned into a chicken and the GM office flooded with two inches of water and the door wouldn't open. So the chicken GM girlfriend had to walk on it's tippy toes and it's chicken feet got all water logged and wrinkly. And Tinnish kept swimming down to slide paper under the door, because he wanted to keep the GM in the loop. And this happened in a school for some reason and there was a bike club which I was more concerned with than anything.

 

f***ing nightmare bro

Old-Timey Member
Posted

No... more... Ball...

 

http://25.media.tumblr.com/dbc6c1749911a2a7f6e63aada006ae54/tumblr_mlh1lnckTq1qh8erdo1_400.gif

Posted
No... more... Ball...

 

http://25.media.tumblr.com/dbc6c1749911a2a7f6e63aada006ae54/tumblr_mlh1lnckTq1qh8erdo1_400.gif

 

Who do you have ahead of Ball though? He certainly isn't my favourite of the projected pool of available players but, he isn't my least favourite either...

Old-Timey Member
Posted
Who do you have ahead of Ball though? He certainly isn't my favourite of the projected pool of available players but, he isn't my least favourite either...

 

Meadows, Smith, Frazier, maybe McGuire, maybe Shipley, Peterson, etc.

 

It's risky banking on some of those guys, but I'm quite sure Smith will be there.

Posted
yes completely going with hype this time, but if jays pick ball over meadows (if available), gonna rage quit on this hopeless team.
Old-Timey Member
Posted
Who do you have ahead of Ball though? He certainly isn't my favourite of the projected pool of available players but, he isn't my least favourite either...

 

Meadows >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Ball. If they take f***ing Ball over Austin Meadows, I will rage. Of course, that's what they will do. Waste a high pick on a guy with a LOT of uncertainty and projection but who is also very athletic. As a pitcher, no less.

 

UGH.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
Meadows, Smith, Frazier, maybe McGuire, maybe Shipley, Peterson, etc.

 

It's risky banking on some of those guys, but I'm quite sure Smith will be there.

 

Smith is nice, but Austin Meadows at 11 is a steal imo. They can't pass on him for a guy like Trey Ball.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
Meadows >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Ball. If they take f***ing Ball over Austin Meadows, I will rage. Of course, that's what they will do. Waste a high pick on a guy with a LOT of uncertainty and projection but who is also very athletic. As a pitcher, no less.

 

UGH.

 

He's exactly what we don't need in two different ways; a projectable pitcher who needs a lot to break right and needs better secondaries, or a toolsy CF with no hit tool.

 

So you just know we're gonna take him.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
Smith is nice, but Austin Meadows at 11 is a steal imo. They can't pass on him for a guy like Trey Ball.

 

I didn't have that in any order.

 

1.) Frazier 2.) Meadows 3.) Smith

 

Smith is a great pick but Meadows or Frazier at 11 would be incredible.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Blue Jays community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...