Really smart and competent isn’t near the cutting edge though and we are in a really tough division.
At the end of the days Cleveland’s MO was being absolutely elite at developing pitching and there is very little evidence that we are anywhere near them in that regard. We aren’t bad,,, we might be getting better… but we definitely didn’t get the best and brightest in that deal.
I was 100% into this move at the time. I thought it made a ton of sense to be ‘Cleveland with money’. That’s a sustainable winning formula. The dodgers basically (and simplistically) became the rays with money and we all see how successful that turned out to be. However, enough time has passed to say we are a LONG way from that goal.
The good thing about baseball is you can still win a World Series like that. But it’s basically impossible to be a sustainable winner like that.