Yes I understand there should be an extent to which you look at the expected results but its been 1.5 years of pathetic results. He is not some youngster where you want to keep giving unlimited chances to.
The fact it took the Jays so long to move him off the closer role was infuriating. I think his performance plays differently if he was moved to the 7th/8th inning role that he's had during the best part of his career.
Also, Hoffman was given a 3 year deal so its harder to cut bait whereas Green was coming off major surgery with less money remaining in regards to tnat comparison.