Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

max silver

Old-Timey Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    7,565

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    6

 Content Type 

Profiles

Toronto Blue Jays Videos

2026 Toronto Blue Jays Top Prospects Ranking

Toronto Blue Jays Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits

Guides & Resources

2025 Toronto Blue Jays Draft Pick Tracker

News

2026 Toronto Blue Jays Draft Tracker: Picks & Bonuses

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by max silver

  1. max silver
    Did you look at any statistics before posting this? Davis Schneider was a 127 wRC+ bat last season who produced 1.3 FWAR in 227 PA off of the bench. That's a fine bench player when he's locked in and producing at the plate, although he's not been producing over the first 5-6 weeks of this season that doesn't erase the success from 2025.
  2. max silver
    Pinango isn't the team's best hitter but he was certainly one of the few performing at the plate. I'd much rather see the team jettison Sosa or option Schneider down to AAA instead but alas that wasn't in the cards.
  3. max silver
    I don't think Bellinger would be producing away from Yankee Stadium to a level commensurate with his contract. He yet again has massive home/away splits this season and I think he's just built for Yankee Stadium. In 2025 and the first 6 weeks of this season Bellinger has a combined 169 wRC+/88 wRC+ home/away split.
  4. max silver
    Lukes was a really valuable contributor for the majority of last season before a September slump. If I recall correctly he was sitting at something approximating 112-115 wRC+ heading into September last season. I do agree he's a platoon bat 4th outfielder type as he can man all of the outfield positions albeit with him being a little stretched athletically in center field.
  5. max silver
    I've been told he's unproven so therefore there's zero chance he's going to help the offense.
  6. max silver
    I'm cutting the guy some slack as it's his first season in the US and he's likely experiencing a bit of culture shock.
  7. max silver
    Must be the "elite" combination of 52% chase/72% chase contact rate.
  8. max silver
    That's not how the conversation unfolded in the first place. I made a perfectly innocuous statement that Barger has potential to add some much needed thump to the lineup once he's locked in at the plate. There is literally nothing to attack in this statement. This was countered with a bunch of strawman style arguments about how I was saying Barger was a savior, or that it I was suggesting it was guaranteed that he would immediately hit to his ceiling. That poster obviously isn't interested or even capable of rationally discussing opinions that run counter to his without pivoting to logical fallacies in reply. If there was single poster on this board who was going to defend that garbage it's no big surprise that it turned out to be you riding in to white knight for this antisocial buffoon.
  9. max silver
    Good grief I should just do myself a favor and add you to my ignore list. You are just so deficient in being a normally functionally adult socially that it's infuriating. I have no displayed zero issues with criticism towards this team, but I have a really hard time dealing with people with below average intelligence who are too slow to be able to recognize their basic deficiencies.
  10. max silver
    Are you being this obtuse intentionally? I am suggesting that Barger is a potential star in the making, and the key factor in him determining this be whether or not he finds more consistency at the plate. I never once suggested that he's somehow proven in any of my posts so you are presenting an argument against a case that I never once tried to make. I never said he's a guaranteed saviour either so stop trying to place words into my mouth. Go back and look at the original post I made towards Barger. At no point did I ever say he was an established star, guaranteed saviour or anything of the sort. I stated that he is a very high ceiling player and if he locks in at the plate as he's capable of he'll be a massive difference maker. If you make an honest attempt at measured conversation vs trying to pick fights based on false premises you'll start to earn a little respect around here. A good starting point for you would be some actual good faith discussion as opposed to the garbage that you are posting here presently.
  11. max silver
    Well look at you Mr. Sour Pants. Instead of choosing to look on the bright side after your team nearly won a world series it's still continuous doom and gloom instead. Addison Barger was a massive difference maker when he was locked in at the plate and this includes a very impressive 188 wRC+ in the post season against very high quality pitching staffs.
  12. max silver
    I think there's a big chance that Addison Barger injects some much needed thump into the lineup once he returns. Barger has shown that he can be a game changer when he's locked in at the plate and all the eludes him from star status is a touch of added consistency at the plate.
  13. max silver
    The Jays chose a good year to get off to a slow start at the plate given how mediocre the AL is as a whole right now. We can only hope that inserting Barger into the lineup helps to kickstart it into gear as it did a season ago.
  14. max silver
    Come on there's no way to expect a guy to survive on such a paltry contract. If he comes back with the stuff and command fully intact after the surgery he's likely still in place for the largest pitcher contract in the sport but that's far from a given.
  15. max silver
    I didn't understand the thinking there either. If you are going to leave a struggling hitter in the lineup in a bases loaded situation late in the game it's worthless to punish him afterwards when he didn't come through in the clutch.
  16. max silver
    I think Heineman has the next 3-4 weeks or so until Kirk is ready to come back to get his bat going a bit. He was the one hitter on the roster that I thought had essentially no chance to repeat his 2025 season with the bat as he outproduced his xwOBA by something like 70 points, but unless he's finished as a major leaguer his bat isn't likely to continue to be as bad as it has been. I don't know if the team will be ready to jettison Heineman as of yet as this would lead to a tenuous situation in terms of catcher depth where if Kirk were to get hurt this could lead to the team being forced to run 2 rookie catchers simultaneously. Valenzuela would likely be better served to be starting 4-5 times per week to continue honing his craft and serving as Kirk's backup would greatly reduce his available playing time.
  17. max silver
    Heineman grades out better at both framing and blocking than Valenzuela. The only real issue with his fielding is his throwing, and he's hovering around an even 0 runs by Statcast presently. There is a teamwork segment in the Statcast catcher stolen base metric and Heineman's teammates haven't been helping him out as this is at -1 runs presently. This all appears as though you are taking a few isolated plays and using the eye test as the metrics do nothing to paint the picture of Heineman being the hopeless defender you are trying to portray him as.
  18. max silver
    Way to tell us you didn't look at the defensive stats before posting this. Heineman is 81st percentile blocking this season and 91st percentile framing. Heineman isn't throwing well this season so at least you were 33% correct. He needs to get his bat going eventually if he wants to remain a Blue Jay but his defense is far from the issue you are falsely claiming it to be.
  19. max silver
    Schneider offers far more offensive upside that Sosa when he's locked in, but Davis has been anything but locked in so far this season. I think one factor keeping him on the big league roster is the lack of an alternative right handed bat to take his place in a platoon role in the outfield.
  20. max silver
    Believe it or not people like to skim through the game threads after the fact. If you want to continue to be treated like the BJMB red headed stepchild then that's your prerogative but stop acting like you are allowed to police when people reply to your inane comments because you don't own this message board.
  21. max silver
    If you can't take the heat get out of the kitchen. Unless everyone puts you on ignore it doesn't really work as it doesn't block the user from seeing replies to your posts. If you don't want to constantly be berated about your semi neurotic posts then stop making so many semi neurotic posts.
  22. max silver
    I am all but certain Bo will eventually heat up with the stick but his numbers so far are eerily similar to the awful 2024 season up to this point. He's once again his own worst enemy at the plate as he's chasing 41% of pitches out of the strike zone and until he cleans this up it's hard to see him going on a run of success.
  23. max silver
    I'd guess Valenzuela would return to AAA to serve as a high end catching depth option and continuing to work on his offensive game. This front office has surprised me more than once though with aggressive moves so it's entirely possible Heineman would be sent packing.
  24. max silver
    Cease hasn't been perfect by any means but he's pacing for a 6+ win season sitting at a 2.13 FIP after 7 starts. He seems to hit a wall partway through most of his starts as he tends to come out of the gate in ace mode before losing his command and/or composure at times when runners find their way onto base. If this is what he continues to provide I'll happily take it but of course more innings per start would be the icing on the cake.
  25. max silver
    If the Jays go on a run similar to last season they are going to rocket up the standings no matter what the rest of the AL does.
×
×
  • Create New...