Nah, I don't buy that. I'm not a McAdoo believer by any means, but Straw and Gimenez suck against LHP, Lukes sucks even worse, and Clement has been awful for months, not 22 random at bats. "The team stinks so let's ignore the splits and just play the vetrins" may not make much of a difference considering the alternatives, but the Jays kinda need to hit on some luck rather than hope 75 wRC+ vets can hold down the fort. I'd much rather see if McAdoo can run into one and then replace him later in the game for defense, but to your greater point, yes the offense sucks either way, so it's not going to be make or break.