I want a manager that knows who his best players are. That's all. Everything else is related to overall talent, luck, etc.
When you start a s***** DH in left, bring in AAAA fodder out of the pen in close games, put one of your best hitters who can't field at 1B to get a backup catcher's bat in the lineup, and so on, and you lead the league in one run losses, at some point you have to not put everything on bad luck and start realizing that runs are being sacrificed by the manager.
AA's moves at the deadline not only added talent but 'dummy proofed' the roster. Even Gibbons is not going to mess this roster up. Much like Cito was given that type of roster in the 90's.