He has a 0.9 WAR in his last 844 plate appearances (2019-20). He has a 0.4 WAR now, which fluctuates a lot due to small sample, but defensive metrics on FG do not like him in CF, he's been a negative base runner since joining the Jays, and whatever adjustment he made in 2019 to lower his strike outs has lessened his biggest strength (power/exit velo/hard hit%). Since 2016, which 2226 plate appearances, he has a .290 OBP and 100 wRC+. Not sure what type of performance you'd be expecting out of him if 2020 were 162 games, but he looks every bit the sub 1 WAR player he was last season, and that's with most of this season happening in August which is like the only month (along with July) that he usually does anything every year. I was cautiously optimistic that the lower K% might lead to something, but he's the same guy. He's a good 4th OF given a starting OF's contract and responsibility. Replacement level or slightly above is semantics. It's not good either way.