I get that. But not all BABIP is not created equal. Vlad still hits the ball incredibly hard. Loft & pull side power has been an issue, as well as being in between late on high V.
It depends on the term/AAV. I have no emotional attachment to Vlad as a player. If he is willing to sign 6/110-120, we have made worse bets.
But given he went to arb hearing over his salary this year after a 1 WAR season, I think he(and his Agent) value himself MUCH higher than most of us do, so tough decisions need to be made soon.