I don't understand Smoak's swing right now. He looks like he's swinging early and opening up his front side a lot, but then his barrel lags behind extremely and somehow he makes contact with the middle portion of the bat.
In Gibby's defense - sort of - he probably thought he was using one of his top arms in Benoit. Probably saw the difference between he and Grilli as too small to mess up his assigned inning roles.
I was about to make a similar comment before the Blue Jays went full retard. Cron played that as poorly as one could possibly play that. Basically waited for the ball to roll fair, giving enough time for the runner to pass him in the process.