Bad contract or not, he was never a great player, just a better than average one. Great is Halladay, Stieb, Alomar, Fernandez, Delgado. Good is Gruber, White, Carter, Wells...and I'd put Wells near the bottom of that list because he never played a meaningful game as a Jay. Not his fault, but still. Greatness comes in the playoffs unless you are exceptional in the regular season, which Wells never was.