You could almost argue that Gimenez was positioned correctly.
McNeil took an awkward inside-out hack that put some bizarre spin on a slow roller, and he still only beat it out by a fraction of a second.
Olerud wants the Jays to position the infielders for this extremely unlikely scenario. Maybe we should have also had Okamoto, Ernie, and Vlad all playing in as well in case a dribbler was hit in their direction? Maybe even bring a 5th infielder into the game to cover the dribblers to an even greater extent?
Heck, just leave Bateman out in CF on his own and bring in 6 infielders to cover all possible dribblers. McNeil wouldn't have had a chance then!
But on the other hand, it had such an extremely low xBA that maybe Gimenez was playing too deep? Who knows but sucks to lose a game that way.